1
Allergy_Man vs. Gopher_Tuna (PBL Round 1)
Which skin do you prefer?
Allergy_Man's skin:
Gopher_Tuna's skin:
Which skin do you prefer?
Allergy_Man's skin:
Gopher_Tuna's skin:
Create an account or sign in to comment.
6
1
Allergy's skin is pretty good and I'm a fan of minimalist shading, but I have to say: Gopher did better with the palette. My vote goes for him.
1
Yes, I may be biased because Matt is one of my best friends. But I think his skin is just a bit better, Allergy did a great job to be honest, his skin is of good quality, the clean shading supports the skin very well. Matt's skin was a bit messy, but when looking close to it, it doesn't matter that much, and it's only really the head I don't like.
The thing that made me vote Matt, was the really weird upper highlight on Allergy's skin. I do not really think that the highlight there does gain the skin too much, contrasts a lot as well.
The thing that made me vote Matt, was the really weird upper highlight on Allergy's skin. I do not really think that the highlight there does gain the skin too much, contrasts a lot as well.
1
Gonna write something so I can check back later easier.
1
I prefer Tuna's shading. It works better, rather than Allergy's skin just being flat colour.
1
Honestly feel as though both of you could've done better with designs and with shading, to a certain degree. Not to say they aren't good skins, but you understand what I'm saying.
Gonna go with Allergy_Man for being slightly more readable, I had assumed Gopher made some sort of diver at first.
Gonna go with Allergy_Man for being slightly more readable, I had assumed Gopher made some sort of diver at first.
1
Personally, Gopher_Tuna did more with the palette, and Allergy's Green Goblin looks more like a Green Gobliness