Under the Sea Skin Contest Discussion Thread!

Challenge the community creativity with your own event.

Post Permalink
by Nyaruko Yasaka » 6/10/2012

creeperCarole wrote:
Emperor Doom wrote:Just to clarify, as I don't think it's ever been stated for one of these contest, are HD skins permitted now that there are people making them?
(for those who don't know, HD Player skins are available through a mod, or just using them as a char.png)

If they're to even be permitted, the only real obstacle would be how to add them.
Long term, I think the most simple solution would be a skins sub-catagory that uses Screenshots instead of the PMC 3d preview.
Short term, would it possible to add the skin without file uploaded, and have the link and screenshot in the description?


it hasn't been stated explicitly, but as one of the rules is a "PLAYABLE" skin, because it requires a mod to use an HD skin, you may not submit one for the contests. Yet.

Because lemme tell you, an HD skin contest would REALLY ROCK. And I'll suggest it.


My only problem with that is that ALL HD skins submitted into the contest (and yes, all HD skins will be by all of the popular / good skinners) will asure them a spot in the finals. It'd be kind of unfair on the normal resolution skins.
Image
User avatar
Level 47
Master Blockhead
Posts: 801
Joined: 1/10/12
Says: Haiyore! Nyaruko-san, watch it now.
Minecraft: Nyaruko_Yasaka

Post Permalink
by Pibz » 6/10/2012

I made a dead pirate. Kind of different I guess. Check it out, it would be much appreciated.

Image
User avatar
Level 12
Journeyman Pokemon
Posts: 1
Joined: 3/14/12

Post Permalink
by creeperCarole » 6/10/2012

Trigger Happy Bunny wrote:
My only problem with that is that ALL HD skins submitted into the contest (and yes, all HD skins will be by all of the popular / good skinners) will asure them a spot in the finals. It'd be kind of unfair on the normal resolution skins.


that's why an HD-skin ONLY contest would need to be done. It would be a specialist skinning contest, obviously as fewer people skin HD.
Image
User avatar
Site Moderator
Level 45
Master Baconator
Posts: 4001
Joined: 5/10/11
Location: My Own Little World
Says: Thank you for the advice, but what I really need are minions.
Minecraft: Branwen
mc_server: creeperCarole's sekrit server

Post Permalink
by Niko » 6/11/2012

hooneybAdgerz wrote:I kind of dislike the under the sea contest.
I don't have much ideas for it and i think it's quite bland, actually.


Be creative. You can't win with an uncreative idea. Many people think that the Under the Sea theme is stupid, just because they have no ideas oO
User avatar
Contest Judge
Level 14
Journeyman Mage
Posts: 353
Joined: 8/6/11

Post Permalink
by RipClaw » 6/12/2012

/me sighs and shakes his head.

Yep, this contest is *cough* drowned in unoriginal submissions. The only thing I've seen in the entire contest are mermaids, sharks, octopi, dead pirates, goo or seaweed monsters, divers, similar "fish" (not very good for skins. It just doesn't work out.), and... Give me a second...
*Looks through 7 more pages*

Well, that's all. There's an occasional (very slightly) original skin such as an underwater shaman or guardian or whatever. Still they're overdone.

There is no originality in this contest. I don't understand if there is a point to this, and I'm very upset with the community for not thinking ahead on how terrible this contest theme would be.

I'm probably not going to enter. There are just no ideas that haven't been overdone, but I'll try and find one. I don't know, this entire contest just is so bad it's just not worth it. If I even enter, it will only be to keep up my "goal" of being a finalist for each contest in a row since the first one I was in... Oh well. PMC is losing its charm anyway. It's only expected for the contest to do so as well.
Image
User avatar
Forum Moderator
Level 56
Grandmaster Skinner
Posts: 1086
Joined: 4/12/11
Says: Says: Says: Says: Says:
Minecraft: RipClaw

Post Permalink
by KnobleKnives » 6/12/2012

This is my contest skin. It has 3D features :geek:

http://www.planetminecraft.com/skin/robo-diver-robert/
Image

"The trick to flying is to throw yourself at the ground and miss."
User avatar
Chat Moderator
Level 50
Grandmaster Nerd
Posts: 268
Joined: 11/29/11
Location: Chillin' out with Zaphod Beeblebrox
Says: "Inconceivable!"
Minecraft: KnobleKnives

Post Permalink
by KnobleKnives » 6/12/2012

creeperCarole wrote:
Trigger Happy Bunny wrote:
My only problem with that is that ALL HD skins submitted into the contest (and yes, all HD skins will be by all of the popular / good skinners) will asure them a spot in the finals. It'd be kind of unfair on the normal resolution skins.


that's why an HD-skin ONLY contest would need to be done. It would be a specialist skinning contest, obviously as fewer people skin HD.


I agree with CreeperCarole. and HD skin contest would be a ton of fun.
Image

"The trick to flying is to throw yourself at the ground and miss."
User avatar
Chat Moderator
Level 50
Grandmaster Nerd
Posts: 268
Joined: 11/29/11
Location: Chillin' out with Zaphod Beeblebrox
Says: "Inconceivable!"
Minecraft: KnobleKnives

Post Permalink
by Rage_Hammer24 » 6/12/2012

must make skin! :D
Image

"What's with all the walls and shiz" -Rage_Blade19
User avatar
Level 8
Apprentice Warrior
Posts: 967
Joined: 2/19/12
Location: Were you left me.
Says: Oops i pulled the lever!
Minecraft: comkreaperkiller, Rage_Hammer24, Alpha_Omega
mc_server: MagnaCraft

Post Permalink
by Blockorz » 6/12/2012

RipClaw wrote:/me sighs and shakes his head.

Yep, this contest is *cough* drowned in unoriginal submissions. The only thing I've seen in the entire contest are mermaids, sharks, octopi, dead pirates, goo or seaweed monsters, divers, similar "fish" (not very good for skins. It just doesn't work out.), and... Give me a second...
*Looks through 7 more pages*

Well, that's all. There's an occasional (very slightly) original skin such as an underwater shaman or guardian or whatever. Still they're overdone.

There is no originality in this contest. I don't understand if there is a point to this, and I'm very upset with the community for not thinking ahead on how terrible this contest theme would be.

I'm probably not going to enter. There are just no ideas that haven't been overdone, but I'll try and find one. I don't know, this entire contest just is so bad it's just not worth it. If I even enter, it will only be to keep up my "goal" of being a finalist for each contest in a row since the first one I was in... Oh well. PMC is losing its charm anyway. It's only expected for the contest to do so as well.

Agreed.That's why I voted for Cyberpunk. Mine is a shark,but I don't expect a high rank..or the finals.
User avatar
Level 27
Expert Blockhead
Posts: 466
Joined: 10/9/11
Location: Your bathroom 3:<
Says: Hold on. My common sense is tingling.
Minecraft: Blockbuds

Post Permalink
by creeperCarole » 6/12/2012

RipClaw wrote:/me sighs and shakes his head.

Yep, this contest is *cough* drowned in unoriginal submissions. The only thing I've seen in the entire contest are mermaids, sharks, octopi, dead pirates, goo or seaweed monsters, divers, similar "fish" (not very good for skins. It just doesn't work out.), and... Give me a second...
*Looks through 7 more pages*

Well, that's all. There's an occasional (very slightly) original skin such as an underwater shaman or guardian or whatever. Still they're overdone.

There is no originality in this contest. I don't understand if there is a point to this, and I'm very upset with the community for not thinking ahead on how terrible this contest theme would be.

I'm probably not going to enter. There are just no ideas that haven't been overdone, but I'll try and find one. I don't know, this entire contest just is so bad it's just not worth it. If I even enter, it will only be to keep up my "goal" of being a finalist for each contest in a row since the first one I was in... Oh well. PMC is losing its charm anyway. It's only expected for the contest to do so as well.


it's easy to criticize something, but a lot harder to come up with suggestions to make things better. I see a lot of the former, and little of the latter. Maybe THAT's why PMC is losing its charm?
Image
User avatar
Site Moderator
Level 45
Master Baconator
Posts: 4001
Joined: 5/10/11
Location: My Own Little World
Says: Thank you for the advice, but what I really need are minions.
Minecraft: Branwen
mc_server: creeperCarole's sekrit server

Post Permalink
by Nickmandont » 6/12/2012

i remember working 3 days on a skin
and it got 10 views
:(
Image
User avatar
Level 14
Journeyman Dragonborn
Posts: 498
Joined: 3/11/12
Location: Canada ftw
Says: Let me tell you, about homestuck :]
Minecraft: Nickmandont

Post Permalink
by 1UPMiner » 6/12/2012

Phew, i think 120 diamonds might get me in the top 100 :3
That is unless everyone else gets 1000 diamonds xD
Oh and any Deep Sea diver skins? i like to see other peoples views on it :D
Last night I lay in bed looking up at the stars in the sky and I thought to myself, "where the heck is the ceiling!".
User avatar
Level 45
Master Dragonborn
Posts: 317
Joined: 7/23/11

PreviousNext

Return to Community Challenges