Planet Minecraft

Hello, i posted something like this before and it was very helpful. So here i go again!

Would you rather play a skyrim type server, dungeons, quests, raiding, grief (assuming your land isnt protected), maybe magic spells and what have you. Would also
have factions, fight mobs and bosses etc.

Or a server set in more modern times, on a island, you crash landed there, you get to explore ancient ruins, as well as
WW2 ruins, Quests, factions, raiding, maybe some griefing (assuming your land isnt protected), mobs, bosses, tombs, dungeons,
and other things. Would also like to include spout for guns and stuff.

Thanks!

Edit:

Both of these ideas would allow players to build bases and stuff

Sound the same to me.

But I'd say neither.. No-one actually does the quests, or the dungeons..

Scrap the quest nonsense, and go with the wrest of the ideas.

Interesting you ask that. I'm the owner of a server similar to the first one you described.

I like that concept more than the second one (which is why I have a server like that). However many players struggle to get over the idea of not building a base, or having to complete quests.