Minecraft Blogs / Article

MCreator Is it really so terrable.

  • 1,783 views, 2 today
  • 2
  • 0
  • 8
INEFFABLE's Avatar INEFFABLE
Level 33 : Artisan Zombie
13
I have recently come across a nifty program called MCreator and found it to be interesting and effective for what its made for but...

It would seam that anyone who has been programming for any decent length of time is getting upset that this program exist. I understand the situation with a program that makes what you do so easy that a "noob" can do it, but does that mean its a bad program?

I see this program as a great place for a "noob" to modding would get a better understanding of how a program work and what they need to know to really make a good mod. It may also change the time it takes to make a mod to be a fraction of the time but I see nothing wrong with it.

If an experienced programmer decided to use this program to develop a new mod then they would come up with a well built mod much faster and they could fine tune the mod in the code itself. That doesn't make it any less of a mod or take away any of its quality. All that changed was the mod took a fraction of the time to make. This means that good mods can be made more often and the programmer can move on to bigger and better things. Is this a problem?

I can see how a bunch of kids would make random BS mods or low quality work but that should not take away from the potential for a great mod to be made from someone who has a great idea but not the best programming skills.

I am sure that MCreator was meant to make a painstakingly long term project just a bit easier and to give the average player a chance to share their ideas.

Maybe MCreator should not be allowed for low level PMC users but people who have reached a level that shows they at least do decent work or work hard on their projects. This would reduce the "spam" of bad mods and allow for decent work to be posted even if that user is not a great programmer. I am sure a level can be decided on by the staff of PMC.

That all being said I would like to know what your thought are on the matter.

FYI: I am not a pro programmer but I understand programming as I do a lot of HTML/XML/Javascript/css and so on. So I would find this program very helpful.

P.S. I can see an arguement for both sides but I still feel that it is less harmfull than it is usefull.
Tags

1 Update Logs

Update #1 : by INEFFABLE 02/26/2014 4:54:26 amFeb 26th, 2014

ps.

Create an account or sign in to comment.

1
03/12/2017 7:41 pm
Level 31 : Artisan Crafter
TheAfrikanDoge
TheAfrikanDoge's Avatar
To me its a good program!
1
02/26/2014 12:07 pm
Level 19 : Journeyman Scribe
Jiloacom
Jiloacom's Avatar
How would an italian chef feel if he had been making his world famous pizza for years, and then some guy who knows nothing about cooking gets some frozen pizza and opens up a pizza parlor right next door from his?
1
02/26/2014 4:46 pm
Level 33 : Artisan Zombie
INEFFABLE
INEFFABLE's Avatar
1st off. it wont taste the same. 2nd the ingredients would be different. 3rd than analogy is not even close to the same idea.
1
02/26/2014 5:00 pm
Level 19 : Journeyman Scribe
Jiloacom
Jiloacom's Avatar
1 and 2. That's the same thing with MCreator mods, but they still take attention away from the real deal. 3. How so?
1
02/18/2014 12:06 pm
Level 24 : Expert Dragon
DBC
DBC's Avatar
Honestly, it makes people happy, so it shouldn't have to be hated on just because of petty excuses of "Its just unfair for us because we know more blablabla D:"... Honestly, its fair access to all who want to use it, even those of you who quote on quote "know more than noobs". Plus, it isn't fair to judge MCJapanga if since he is the one actually helping people who don't spend all their time being "PMC Nerds" and spend all their time trying to get levels... Honestly, it is really pitiful that this would even be posted over something that helps people, rather than not share it just so "noobs" have no idea on what to do just to have something better than them.. Plus, maybe someone just wants to make a mod for personal use, but doesn't know where to start. What if they wanted to make something to play with their "friends"? And so what if they post it on PMC, if it makes people happy, then they would be doing something right.
1
03/12/2017 7:41 pm
Level 31 : Artisan Crafter
TheAfrikanDoge
TheAfrikanDoge's Avatar
I agree I don't like coding!
1
02/18/2014 5:55 pm
Level 33 : Artisan Zombie
INEFFABLE
INEFFABLE's Avatar
Ya I don't understand why skilled programmers hate MCreator so much. Its a useful tool and good to have around so why so much hate.

I wish there was a section in PMC for those mods. It would alleviate the problem IMO.
1
02/13/2014 3:55 pm
Level 1 : New Explorer
Insomniaadmin
Insomniaadmin's Avatar
I agree with the idea of allowing well known or high level programmers / modder to be allowed to use MCreator.

I see no reason why that would be a problem should be easy enough to set up so it can be controlled.
Planet Minecraft

Website

© 2010 - 2024
www.planetminecraft.com

Welcome