Minecraft Blogs / Article

Music Disc 11 CASE SOLVED!

  • 55,553 views, 11 today
  • 13
  • 5
  • 18
Cows n Cotton avatar Cows n Cotton
Level 52 : Grandmaster Cowboy
I have been investigating on what is happpening in the music disc 11, and the answer to the question is basically told to us by the person who created the disc, C418, and is simpler than you would have thought. 

     I have made conclusions in a previous blog about the in-game music disc, found here. I have realized that outside of the game files C418 has made a music clip named "11" or "eleven", the exact same name as the broken disc. Both discs start with a static sound, infering that both discs are cracked to some point. My theory on this is that the in-game music disc is the exact same as the outside music disc, but the one in-game is more damaged, and this explains the random ambience in the background of the in-game music disc. Both music discs, inside and outside the game are both confirmed to be made by C418. Therefore, both music discs are the same because they are both made by the same creator with the same name and the exact same length.

    The music disc  is the same disc, in-game and outside. Therefore, the music disc is more damaged in the in-game version, because it has more static noise than the outside disc and the item icon shows the disc is nearly destroyed. This only means that the in-game disc was damaged and beaten somehow, and that it used to have the calm piano of the outside disc. The disc in-game is actually the outside disc, but damaged horribly. The walking sounds can be explained as enlargened gaps in the disc, the cough is pretty hard to do, but it could happen, and the tinkering sounds can be explained as the distorted music, same with the ambience in the background. it is pretty clear that the music disc is a distorted version of the outside disc, and this was it all along. Sorry, Herobrine, there's no place for you in this disc.

Therefore, this simple and best-proven theory on the disc is more than likely to be the answer, as the creator of the disc gave it away, and I think i'm the first to bring this theory of the disc up.

If you cant play the thumbnail video of the outside disc:

If you want to hear the in-game disc:

As usual, comments or other theories accepted.
CreditYoutube, C418, Minecraft

Create an account or sign in to comment.

11/11/2019 12:32 pm
Level 14 : Journeyman Architect
frazzleman10 avatar
the underman and hero brine thing is fake the whole thing is a creeper chasing a miner in a cave, both disk 11 and disk 13 are related. if you would like to read more then heres the link that i found here
07/01/2019 6:15 pm
Level 1 : New Miner
prussia_and_gilbird avatar
so i found something out so what you do is just simply rewind or reverse the disc and at the beginning you can here the enderman saying hey in its distorted glory case solved it was a enderman chasing a miner of sorts in a cave
03/12/2019 6:12 pm
Level 1 : New Miner
JirvolAndBurdock avatar
I made a video about this on Youtube (under the name of otherkin cringe) and I never knew that C418 himself confirmed it, but I did know about the out-of-game track.
03/11/2018 9:59 pm
Level 1 : New Miner
rexthewarlord avatar
it sounds creepy to me. i did the disc 11 challenge but nothing happened execpt i found a deserted village with no one there and it wasent a zombie one either.
01/21/2018 5:00 am
Level 1 : New Miner
CoolBoy301 MC+
CoolBoy301 MC+ avatar
According to AntVenoms vid, he claims that the Disc 11 plays this: A man running through a cave coughing and seems to be hearing or being chased by a enderman. AntVenom says he claims that he hears that.
11/01/2016 8:14 am
Level 1 : New Miner
HeroBrine127 avatar
Guys I tried something in Minecraft with discs. Well I took a jukebox and placed a redstone comparator in front of it. I put a line of redstone dust (about like 20 blocks long). I put different discs and each gave different output. However, the c418 - 11 disc gave exactly 11 blocks redstone power!!!! Well you may think it is according to number for other discs. C418-13 gives only 2 blocks.

Well c418 is special. This is one of the hints that wasnt ever discovered.
10/18/2016 1:37 am
Level 1 : New Miner
Tassiekayaker101 avatar
The clicking in 11 is obviously flint and steel, and then theres a nether portal sound directly after it
01/05/2015 1:37 pm
Level 48 : Master Sweetheart
Zatharel avatar
fun theory :p
01/05/2015 2:51 am
Level 37 : Artisan uwu
Nekomancy avatar
I couldn't have done any of this better myself xD. Frankly, I thought it was a joke from Mojang in the first place for when people started crying "I SAW HEROBRINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!" as that seems to be like.. the only thing that people refer this disc to... Herobrine. .-.,

Eh I talk too much.
01/04/2015 8:04 pm
Level 50 : Grandmaster Prince
Prince Oceanus
Prince Oceanus avatar
-facepalm- Just....why? Why are we just now figuring this out NOW? And I figured this "11" Music Disc crap a long time ago. All they did was make a hint at Endermen, which they added in after the "11" Music Disc Update. And the Illuminati have nothing to do with this. Again, just another kid trying to get attention on YouTube.
Planet Minecraft


© 2010 - 2021