• 4
• 0
• 10
• • Diamond Log
  • Embed
  • Report

In the last days i've been thinking, i've made a lot of projects, but i haven't heard a lot of feedback from experienced minecraft players. So what if we would have a review section in PMC.

Overall idea:

Review Section in PMC

Why should it be made?
A lot of us here in PMC who make projects would like to hear thoughts from other project makers. Actual detail reviews with ratings. It would be nice if you could actualy know if what you made is good or bad. Sometimes you can get confused, you can be spammed with comments from 10 year olds saying: "YOUR MAP IS AMAZING!" , but maybe thats the first map he has ever played and he thinks that even something really bad is amazing. My point is, we want a place where experienced people could give as actual ratings and tell as what to fix or how to make something better.


How should it be made?

We wouldn't want ten year olds rating over stuff badly just cause they forgot to turn difficulty to peaceful and creepers blew everything up. What if the section had built in rating system for every type of map/project. Like for a adventure map you would have to choose from 1 to 10 in all of these points: Innovation Detail Experience Challenge Progression. You would just have to post the link to the map in a certain place, and it would detect which map you have rated. You would also have to write about why you rated stuff the way you did with more than a few words. Everybody could post reviews, but the section wouldn't be spammed, because those who are lazy will not take the time to write stuff about the map.

How can you know if the ratings aren't from friends or fake ones?

There could be a reviewer award you could earn by posting a lot of great reviews. And then then there would be two scores, the reviewer rating and the overall rating. What would that change? Well the score of the map would be told by the reviewer ratings , because then you will know that the ratings are from people who are good at posting reviews. And the rating system would also bring some cool adittions like, Most rated map of the day, Top 10 rated maps of the year, Best reviewers, and much more.

So my point is, that we need this section , they way it would be made wouldn't necessarily be how i want it to be. But the fact that there would be a section, would inspire creators to create better stuff.

DO YOU AGREE? If you want a section then post this in the comments:

I'm [Your Username] , and i want a review section!

Who knows, if we get a lot of these, we might make this possible! The more we get the more we'll be noticed!


DIAMOND, and let other people know about this idea ;)