forum Forumsplay_arrow Communities fiber_manual_record Artists

1

Need Honest Opinion on A Logo I Made

1 emerald18 replies500 views
created 10/30/2013 4:40 pm by The Gaming Grunts
last reply 10/30/2013 5:59 pm
Hey everyone! I'm just looking for some feedback on a simple logo I made for my soon-to be released server. To me honest, I threw it together in about 5 minutes, but I'd still like some feedback on it to see what would make it look better. Thanks in advance

http://i.imgur.com/vWKa3Xf.png

All feedback is appreciated, whether it's good or bad. I'd rather have someone tell me straight-up that it sucks rather than pretend to like it

Small Edit: So you guys know, the background will be added later. This is just the basic logo.
Posted by avatar
The Gaming Grunts
Level 15 : Journeyman Pokemon
11

18 replies

1
10/30/2013 5:57 pm
Level 47 : Master Artist
janidorr
avatar
RustyTurkeyBrainThe background advice is poor as it is a lgoo and logos do not have backgrounds.
For example; Minecraft logo, google logo, skype logo, windows logo and PRACTICALLY EVER LOGO!


Not all logos have transpariences behind them. There are quite a few that are pretty well known with a background. It also adds flair and contrast to the logo.
1
10/30/2013 5:52 pm
Level 15 : Journeyman Pokemon
The Gaming Grunts
avatar
Thanks for the feedback everyone I just wanted to know what people thought of it so I'd know whether or not to do anything with it
1
10/30/2013 5:35 pm
Level 37 : Artisan Taco
Rice
avatar
I think it looks good, also your signature with the video covers up other people's posts
1
10/30/2013 5:16 pm
Level 52 : Grandmaster Terraformer
Ivain
avatar
honestly, its qutie difficult to judge a logo as small as that, expecially without background. whatever background you will add, make sure the sides are not too empty.

Apart from that, it seems ok, though I would personally make the border a bit thinner, and instead of pure black use a very dark shade of red or green, or whatever color fits best.
that's all for now, I can tell you more when you've added the background.
1
10/30/2013 5:15 pm
Level 86 : Elite War Lord
Kefka
avatar
the #1 important thing for a logo is legibility (easy to read)

The black borders around the letters are too thick and the Project-X wording is too hard to read.

Also, the logo is a bit boring, give it something besides just letters. Do some research of other logos to get some ideas.
1
10/30/2013 5:08 pm
Level 26 : Expert Network
Corsicaman
avatar
It doesn't really look professional. If I was you I'd ask a pro to make one for me.
1
10/30/2013 4:58 pm
Level 47 : Master Architect
DustyDesigns
avatar
Well actually I don't really find it a logo. It's just a main text. EVEN if you are adding background, it still stays text. A logo is something which represents a company, team, server, without saying the name... Right?
1
10/30/2013 5:59 pm
Level 1 : New Miner
XeroElixir
avatar
That's what I always thought of a logo, I'd have to agree with him. It doesn't really appear to be a logo. Although I would consider abbreviated text a logo. Such as my name is XeroElixir, Xero, or Xro would look fine, But plain text, No.

I also disagree with a background.
1
10/30/2013 5:03 pm
Level 15 : Journeyman Pokemon
The Gaming Grunts
avatar
1
10/30/2013 5:15 pm
Level 47 : Master Architect
DustyDesigns
avatar
Thank you for stating my point.
1
10/30/2013 4:53 pm
Level 31 : Artisan Electrician
RustyTurkeyBrain
avatar
Guys I don't think you understand. The background advice is poor as it is a lgoo and logos do not have backgrounds.
For example; Minecraft logo, google logo, skype logo, windows logo and PRACTICALLY EVER LOGO!
I could give you crits on it but I'm not nice, so I'll not do that xD
1
10/30/2013 4:56 pm
Level 15 : Journeyman Pokemon
The Gaming Grunts
avatar
I added that to the main post so people don't keep saying it
1
10/30/2013 4:50 pm
Level 14 : Journeyman Engineer
NuclearManx
avatar
Cool... but but you should probably remove your name at the bottom and create a background.
1
10/30/2013 4:49 pm
Level 20 : Expert Robot
D1v1d3m4n
avatar
Add some background, primarily one with some "Huzzah!" Overall, It's pretty decent.
1
10/30/2013 4:45 pm
Level 1 : New Miner
ProBuilder28
avatar
its pretty cool, but it could be better. I would add backgrounds and twist things around, things don't always have to be horizontal. Add in images as well, to make it look even cooler. that's just my opinion, tho, u can do what u want.
1
10/30/2013 4:49 pm
Level 15 : Journeyman Pokemon
The Gaming Grunts
avatar
I'm going to add the background later. This is just the basic logo
1
10/30/2013 4:44 pm
Level 16 : Journeyman Scribe
-abs-106-
avatar
Honestly its a pretty good logo. Only thing I would suggest is some sort of background which I assume your adding soon.
1
10/30/2013 4:48 pm
Level 15 : Journeyman Pokemon
The Gaming Grunts
avatar
Thanks I'm going to add the background later. This is just the basic logo

Planet Minecraft

Browse

Site

© 2010 - 2019
planetminecraft.com

Welcome