Never really played anything scary due to super-protective parents, so I would have to say Metroid Prime Hunters (I think), although it's not scary at all now(It was when I was six, though.)

Lego Batman.

That crap is scary as hell.

for me its S.T.A.L.K.E.R

Amnesia for sure.. Such a scary, but good game =D

More than scary, Minecraft ( but only when you play it alone during the night) screws with your mind, in facts you don't need blood, cut arms, violence, etc... to feel the paranoid sensation. Isn't it?

Protip to people who wants to avoid nighttime and has no iron: Kill 3 sheep and punch a tree LIKE A BLAUWK!

Minecraft because of one time i was trying to kill a creeper and another jumped right in front of my damn screen, scared the cripes out of me...

amnesia dark decent scares the crap out of me

This is pretty much what happens in Minecraft for me.

... .. ... ... ... ... ...
Series of real events.
1) Playing Minecraft. 2) still playing minecraft. 3) See creeper by your house. 4) Creeper blows up and you get frustrated. 5) You realize the damage he's done. 6) You kill every creeper you see in Minecraft for revenge 7) Continue playing Minecraft normally.

Minecraft is scary because you can never leave it.

Thats not scary.
This is:
[youtube]www.youtube.com/watch?v=CFr4Kang6oo[/youtube]

Gumybear song and its not original...told you it was scary XD

Amnesia is so much worse.

I was playing minecraft and I saw something unusual: Take a look

Frankly, Those games don't scare me much anymore. Only "Fatal Frame" (Much scarier than Amnesia), and "Barbie's Horse Adventures" scare me now!

If you're scared of Minecraft, then you will pee your pants playing Amnesia.

amnesia the dark descent

Eh? Not the scaryiest game but at some times, pretty creepy since creepers got a new AI change up

I was scared of the green p---s at first. Now amnesia scares me.

tf2... i still here sniper rifles in my dreams....

How is it scary though I only think its scary when you place a torch then a monster appears right there but its not scary like that only like a surprising kind of scare.


It was only scary when I first heard of Herobrine.

I generally don't play 'scary' games. But i have to say, minecraft with headphones in when you're alone in the house at night is absolutely terrifying.

minecraft is scary and stressful

I'm scared for my structures. damn creepers are always blowing them up when I'm halfway done.

we got 10 pages yay

The scariest game for me. Definitely not minecraft maybe Majora'a mask you can't tell me that Tingle isn't scary <shudder>

I rarely get scared on mincraft when I first got the game I got a fright in the dark cave or when there was a creeper behide me and I didn't know but not anymore i am fright proof

[deleted]

But, I think we've got the point. Dead Space, Amnesia and Farmville are the scariest games ever. Minecraft can just freak you out only sometimes.

because it an awesome topic

Errr, why do we need to keep this going?

lets get a 100 pages of talking about scary games

i agree lets keep going with this what are more scary games

(i have this topic in my bookmarks bar because its awesome)

lol i just had to change my pants after seeing a creeper XD

minecraft doesnt really always "SCARE" me but every once nd a while ill get spooked by something

Minecraft scary? Eh, I've jumped a lot in Minecraft, but out of surprise, like when an arrow comes flying out of the dark. Makes me jump every time. Hate Skeletons..... But after the initial surprise, it's just murdering time as always.

Amnesia *shivers*