Hello! I'm currently working on the mod Whimsy Wishes, which I'll be releasing in June. This mod adds Sparkles, a harmless mob that can spawn in the dark. When this creature is killed, player can choose one of 3 wishes.

If you have any wish ideas, feel free to share them in the comments!
If your idea is used, your name will be included in the mod’s description when it’s released.
If you have any wish ideas, feel free to share them in the comments!
If your idea is used, your name will be included in the mod’s description when it’s released.
Create an account or sign in to comment.
7

I wish that one of the wishes would be a wish to wish Magnifico from Wish into the game, allowing players to then wish to Magnifico, giving up said wish to Magnifico, meaning they can never wish that wish again from the wish-granting Sparkles.
Jokes aside, Magnifico could spawn with all the wishes as Sparkles, and, when one is chosen, that wish would be eliminated from the list of wishes Sparkles can spawn with. This doesn't do much to aid the player at the time, but if one wish that Sparkles spawns with is particularly useless to a certain player, this gives the player a chance to never see that option again, with that option being replaced by better ones, theoretically.
Jokes aside, Magnifico could spawn with all the wishes as Sparkles, and, when one is chosen, that wish would be eliminated from the list of wishes Sparkles can spawn with. This doesn't do much to aid the player at the time, but if one wish that Sparkles spawns with is particularly useless to a certain player, this gives the player a chance to never see that option again, with that option being replaced by better ones, theoretically.

Thanks for the idea! I’m not sure if I’ll add Magnifico specifically, but I really like the concept, so I’ll try to add something similar.

I wish that my custom minecraft client works

I wish for unicorns

Abstract and generalize a bit and…
"Find me a companion" providing an equine (horse, donkey, mule, maybe a skelton horse) or a llama, dog, cat might be interesting (I can't think of any other mobs one would consider a companion other than the 'happy ghast'/casper which seems too overpowered).
"Find me a companion" providing an equine (horse, donkey, mule, maybe a skelton horse) or a llama, dog, cat might be interesting (I can't think of any other mobs one would consider a companion other than the 'happy ghast'/casper which seems too overpowered).

I'm working on the assumption (based on the examples) that the 'wishes' need to be fairly general (as oppssed to wishing for a stack of comparators).
In addition to "Become rich" (presumably diamonds/gold/meralds), you might add "Gear me up" which might be further split to armor/shields and weapons/tools ("Arm me up" & "Equip me").
"Feed me" seems like it ought be on the list as a standard fantasy trope, although I can't see it being much used in MC [vanilla].
"Seeds please" (including carrots, potatoes, saplings, vines, and [maybe] the nether plants) might be quite useful early game.
"Brewmeister, still again" (giving a poition) would likely get at least some use.
"Mine for me" granting some quantity of one of the usual mined resources (iron, gold, redstone, lapis, diamond, etc) might see use early on (possibly returning ores rather than refined resources).
In addition to "Become rich" (presumably diamonds/gold/meralds), you might add "Gear me up" which might be further split to armor/shields and weapons/tools ("Arm me up" & "Equip me").
"Feed me" seems like it ought be on the list as a standard fantasy trope, although I can't see it being much used in MC [vanilla].
"Seeds please" (including carrots, potatoes, saplings, vines, and [maybe] the nether plants) might be quite useful early game.
"Brewmeister, still again" (giving a poition) would likely get at least some use.
"Mine for me" granting some quantity of one of the usual mined resources (iron, gold, redstone, lapis, diamond, etc) might see use early on (possibly returning ores rather than refined resources).

Thanks for your suggestions! I'll try to add all of your suggestions except Mine for me.