Shading? Phetagorah.

Detail? Phetogorah.

Originality? Phetogorah.

Overly popular and famous? Brain_Juice.

So I'm gonna have to go with Brain's. No, not Brain_Juice, I mean my brains.

Phetogorah

Ooo tough one.
Phetagorah, good shading, I like the shaping on the different bits of the suit.
Brain, I like the combo of the dark blues and reds a lot.

Voting Brain because he used the palette a little better.

I went for Phetagorah, his shading was more well done, but good luck to the both of you.

Brain's was too smooth. Went for Phetagorah (who?)

I voted for Phetagorah for his brilliant use of the hat layer. Good luck to both of you.

Brain_Juice's is really good looking, but no creativity. P lame skin design, but the shading and colors are great. (Not like I can talk about creativity though.)

As for zRav's, I like the original skin design a lot, but it's only orange and blue, and I think more could've been gotten out of the palette.

I think I might vote for Brain_Juice?

Tough one.