1
XDInsanity's skin
http://www.planetminecraft.com/skin/medic-pbls6w4/
Neo's skin
http://www.planetminecraft.com/skin/pbl-black-mage/
http://www.planetminecraft.com/skin/medic-pbls6w4/
Neo's skin
http://www.planetminecraft.com/skin/pbl-black-mage/
Create an account or sign in to comment.
23
1
i vot both k
1
the voting has already ended, none of your votes matter. stop please.
1
They're both great skins, but I'm going with Neo's skin.
1
Easy choice XDInstanity
1
Oooooo. It's a tie so far 33-33
1
the voting has already ended.
1
tie!?
1
Tie again! 29-29. I voted for Neo, it just appeals to me more overall.
1
gosh darn it guys
stop making this so hard
stop making this so hard
1
Tie, once again, thanks to me. I voted Neo.
1
XDInsanityXDInsanity's skin
http://www.planetminecraft.com/skin/medic-pbls6w4/
Neo's skin
http://www.planetminecraft.com/skin/pbl-black-mage/
I went with XD since from when I first saw Neo's skin I had NO idea what it was until I read the name.
1
tie breaker , i go for neo
1
19-19 Tie!
1
XDInsanity begged me to vote for him c.c
I don't like voting when the competition is quite tight, so it's like voting for both
I don't like voting when the competition is quite tight, so it's like voting for both
1
Hehe my shading again... that's just my style but thanks for the feedback you all!
EDIT: Insanity, can you add links to the skins? Much appreciated
EDIT: Insanity, can you add links to the skins? Much appreciated
1
I'll admit, Neo's skin is pretty cool. However, XDInsanity's skin is more detailed and far more interesting overall. Sorry Neo.
1
Ok, I love Neo's skin. I think the idea and use of layers is flawless. Buuuuut, XD used the palette a little better, imo. Tough decision.
1
Going with Neo. XD's skin's head looks too weird.
1
I'm going to judge you on how they judge PMC skin contests.
XD:
Originality:33/50 I almost never see medic skins, but they are still out there.
Shading: 42/50 You can easily tell the arm and the body a part without you having to have a line to separate it. I also like the simple, barely complex way of shading.
Final Score: 75/100
Neo:
Originality: 26/50 I see many black mage skins, but your efforts to use new colors raised the originality.
Shading:33/50 Don't get me wrong, I like simple skins. But, you used the two colors in many areas. Yet, it stall has a shading I like.
Final Score: 59/100
Review:
XD try using more original skins. Don't worry about your shading.
Neo again, try using more rare skins, or new ones. Try making your shading more complex.
Neo and XD you are both great skinners. Continue to make more skins. But, my vote goes to XD. Good luck to both of you!
XD:
Originality:33/50 I almost never see medic skins, but they are still out there.
Shading: 42/50 You can easily tell the arm and the body a part without you having to have a line to separate it. I also like the simple, barely complex way of shading.
Final Score: 75/100
Neo:
Originality: 26/50 I see many black mage skins, but your efforts to use new colors raised the originality.
Shading:33/50 Don't get me wrong, I like simple skins. But, you used the two colors in many areas. Yet, it stall has a shading I like.
Final Score: 59/100
Review:
XD try using more original skins. Don't worry about your shading.
Neo again, try using more rare skins, or new ones. Try making your shading more complex.
Neo and XD you are both great skinners. Continue to make more skins. But, my vote goes to XD. Good luck to both of you!
1
XDInsanity made a great skin out of the palette, so I'm going with him.
1
Like Neo's skin but XD's has more shading