forum Forumsplay_arrow Minecraft fiber_manual_record Skins

1

Skin Battle - Allergy_Man vs Pikamoar

1 emerald19 replies457 views
created 04/29/2015 2:32 pm by Punkamoar
last reply 05/01/2015 8:59 am
I challenged Allergy to a skin battle, so we did. But instead of saying who made which skin, we are gonna do this anonymously. Hopefully this step will remove some biased voting, in either direction.

Skin #1:


Skin #2:


Our theme was making Amon from The Legend of Korra:
Posted by avatar
Punkamoar
Retired Moderator
Level 50 : Grandmaster Gent
539

19 replies

1
05/01/2015 8:59 am
Level 56 : Grandmaster Terraformer
Myyoyo
avatar
Skin #1 - Nice chestplate
Skin #2 - Nice hood
1
04/30/2015 11:54 pm
Level 86 : Elite War Lord
Kefka
avatar
Its harder to judge without a 3d preview
1
04/30/2015 11:45 pm
Level 59 : Grandmaster Pixel Puncher
PixelCrash_
avatar
I really like the idea of an anonymous poll, but Pikamoar's shading style is too recognizable.

While they're both really close in terms of quality, I have to give my vote to skin 2. The shading on skin 1 is okay but the colors are a bit dull in comparison.

good luck to both of you
1
04/30/2015 4:23 pm
Level 45 : Master Pixel Painter
Waffleman112
avatar
I like #2 better, but I know nothing about skins, I just prefer the second one both of them are good though.
1
04/30/2015 4:10 pm
Level 7 : Apprentice Architect
PuddinPup
avatar
#1 does not even have the hood, so the choice was so obvious.
1
04/30/2015 3:06 pm
Level 66 : High Grandmaster Button Pusher
DragonsDungeon
avatar
I'm just voting for the better skin you know. So I vote for Allergy's skin in this one.

You all know which skin is his anyway, it's so obvious.
1
04/30/2015 3:07 pm
Level 50 : Grandmaster Gent
Punkamoar
avatar
Not everyone does know though, and the people who do will be mature enough to not vote based on popularity.
1
04/30/2015 4:06 pm
Level 36 : Artisan Cake
CalPal_
avatar
That is the hope, at least.
1
04/30/2015 5:38 am
Level 17 : Journeyman Cowboy
Jex_Infinite
avatar
The first one had the colours all good, but the face is botched and ugly. Bad face.

2 does the colours more dramatically, and looks more like Amon.
1
04/30/2015 5:14 am
Level 16 : Journeyman Network
YTCereal
avatar
second one , cuz its more like Amon

But first one is like a man wearing a mask and wearing iron armor
1
04/30/2015 1:16 am
Level 55 : Grandmaster Senpai
AnimeFanFTW
avatar
The 2nd one. It looks amaze
1
04/30/2015 12:15 am
Level 57 : Grandmaster Scapegoat
Gab_Cab
avatar
1 is an overall better skin but 2 looks more like Amon
1
05/01/2015 8:53 am
Level 61 : High Grandmaster Sweetheart
Myraaa
avatar
1
04/29/2015 11:18 pm
Level 25 : Expert Artist
Creatable
avatar
I like the design of the 2nd one, but i like the color palette of the 1st.
I vote for 1.5
1
04/29/2015 11:16 pm
Level 49 : Master Batman
Samakes
avatar
They both stink (^:
1
04/30/2015 2:52 pm
Level 50 : Grandmaster Gent
Punkamoar
avatar
So do you <3
1
04/29/2015 2:38 pm
Level 35 : Artisan Dolphin
Masq
avatar
I could kind of tell who's was who's due to skinning style but that's beside the point

I voted for skin 2 just because I think it tackled the head/hood better.
1
04/30/2015 12:01 am
Level 24 : Expert Blacksmith
StingRay_FTW
avatar
I agree with TT.
Also, the clothings color matches the reference more than #1's.
Plus, #2 had the arm armor that #1 did not.
And finally, #2 acknowledged that his jacket had buttons, which #1 lacked.

I'd cast my vote for #2.
1
04/29/2015 2:36 pm
Level 48 : Master Princess
Woo
avatar
Its so easy to tell :^)

Planet Minecraft

Browse

Site

© 2010 - 2019
planetminecraft.com

Welcome