14

Pros and Cons of The Two Minecraft Versions.

McAlpake11/8/24 1:58 pm history
14 emeralds 814 119
12/27/2024 2:05 pm
McAlpake
I switched to Java a while ago but decided to give Bedrock another try. Here’s what happened. I started off with a classic survival playthrough, and right away, things took a turn. The day cycle seemed to fly by — it was literally night in what felt like five seconds. As soon as the sun set, a skeleton began relentlessly spamming arrows at me, and to make matters worse, my health never regenerated. Needless to say, it didn’t go well.


This got me thinking about my time with Java. In contrast, when I play Java, I feel like the gameplay is much smoother, especially with all the optimization mods like Sodium and Lithium. My health seems to regenerate properly, and the day-night cycle feels more balanced. The vast modding community also adds so much extra content that Bedrock simply doesn’t have — like custom world generation mods, performance tweaks, and extensive gameplay enhancements. It’s those little things that make Java feel more polished to me.


Next, I decided to explore Bedrock’s servers, beginning with one of the most popular: The Hive. This server offers a wide variety of mini-games, so I chose to dive into BedWars solos. The first thing that happened? I was instantly killed by a hacker. It was frustrating, to say the least. In Java, I’d typically encounter similar issues, but the variety of anti-cheat plugins and community-driven efforts to deal with hackers makes it feel less frequent. Plus, with Java, I can always jump into a modded server to play unique game modes that aren't available on Bedrock.


That’s just my experience, of course. Everyone’s gameplay can be different, and I wanted to share my thoughts on it.


UPDATE: I just want to remind everyone to keep the conversation respectful. This post is meant to be a place where we can all share our opinions and experiences without any hostility. Let's keep it fun and interesting for everyone.
Posted by
McAlpake
Level 22 : Expert Zombie Fisherman
53

Create an account or sign in to comment.

119

Tarruvi
11/13/2024 9:20 pm
Level 18 : Journeyman Dragonborn
The marketplace is rife with stolen work, it's wild that Microsoft is fully endorsing stolen work for profit,
6
McAlpake
11/13/2024 10:52 pm
He/Him • Level 22 : Expert Zombie Fisherman
Yeah, it's just a bunch of brainrot
6
DoreoTheOreo
11/17/2024 7:49 am
He/Him • Level 37 : Artisan Dragonborn Nerd
yeah
3
Zomphey
11/09/2024 10:59 am
He/Him • Level 47 : Master Blueberry Blob
You think the amazing thing that is About - The Hive Forumscame from the underworld?


Go and check out lifeboat my dude, it came from the deepest depths of ****.
6
markl1zard
11/11/2024 8:21 am
It/It • Level 32 : Artisan Herobrine Herobrine
history
And java version of width=20 is totaly a 5h!t
2
ohio920dagamer
11/15/2024 10:46 pm
He/Him • Level 26 : Expert Procrastinator
They made the ranks subscriptions for whatever god-forsaken reason, and they're not adding the old gamemodes (ADD TD BACK!!!) anytime soon..
3
McAlpake
11/11/2024 1:45 pm
He/Him • Level 22 : Expert Zombie Fisherman
Ye especially since they use java pvp with bedwars lol.
3
Zomphey
11/11/2024 10:22 am
He/Him • Level 47 : Master Blueberry Blob
ik right, I played it once, and I never really wanted to play it again afterwards.
2
DoreoTheOreo
11/16/2024 11:40 am
He/Him • Level 37 : Artisan Dragonborn Nerd
same
2
McAlpake
11/09/2024 12:33 pm
He/Him • Level 22 : Expert Zombie Fisherman
How u get that emoji?
2
Zomphey
11/09/2024 12:52 pm
He/Him • Level 47 : Master Blueberry Blob
I inserted an image and made it smol

No emoji :(
2
DoreoTheOreo
11/17/2024 7:49 am
He/Him • Level 37 : Artisan Dragonborn Nerd
i feel like bedrock has more sweats than java
4
IGEBM
11/13/2024 7:36 pm
He/Him • Level 57 : Grandmaster Loremaster
Alright, I disagree with your point for reasons stated by many others in the comments, so I won’t go into that. What I will do, however, is defend the Hive: speaking as someone who plays that server for at least an hour every night, it’s pretty good. Sure, it’s no Hypixel, but it really isn’t that bad, and I’m not lying when I say that I’ve literally never encountered a hacker on there. (Your experience is like, the second or third time I’ve heard about it happening lol)
4
McAlpake
11/13/2024 8:11 pm
He/Him • Level 22 : Expert Zombie Fisherman
Once you do (If you play skywars) will probably not like it as much.
1
IGEBM
11/13/2024 9:39 pm
He/Him • Level 57 : Grandmaster Loremaster
lol I doubt that’ll happen (me no longer enjoying a server bc of one hack)
2
McAlpake
11/13/2024 10:51 pm
He/Him • Level 22 : Expert Zombie Fisherman
lol
2
ohio920dagamer
11/13/2024 7:10 pm
He/Him • Level 26 : Expert Procrastinator
here's my comparison...
MODDING
Java wins. (Thousands for free!)
PLAYER COUNT

Bedrock wins. (A lot of java servers kind of lack players)
MICROTRANSACTIONS (lack thereof)
Java wins. (aside from the ones in servers)
PLAYER TYPE
Java has older, veteran players.
Bedrock has newer, younger players.
Java is better but bedrock works if you have nothing else, I guess.
4
Cornbread_Alphanumeric
12/27/2024 5:21 am
She/They • Level 45 : Master Miner uwu
history
i feel like the biggest reason java edition has more mods is just because it's older, meaning there are more tools for people to make more mods with, driving up demands for more tools, and so on. kinda like how there are a quadrillion mods for super mario brothers, but not as many for super mario all stars. i can't help but wonder how far along bedrock mods would be in terms of quality had people kept making them.

microtransactions... exist on java edition. it even has what is effectively paid dlc (albeit, without the dl part). it isn't as bad as the marketplace, obvi, but it does still exist.

and, when it comes to player type, i would simply like to remind everyone that bedrock edition's alpha predates java edition's release. veteran bedrock players exist.

i'm not mad btw. i'm just not sure how to phrase this that it doesn't read like i am.
1
amateurpainter32
11/12/2024 2:42 pm
He/Him • Level 5 : Apprentice Architect
Bedrock is pretty much just a cow that microsoft can milk for money by selling all of that paid-for stuff
4
MonkeManII
11/09/2024 12:51 pm
He/Him • Level 29 : Expert Procrastinator Procrastinator
TIME OF DAY: false, you probably left the game "paused" (it doesn't actually pause)

I feel like bedrock is just a different game than Java. Its combat does sucks- no strategy, all autoclickers and that there's virtually no health regen. I also despise the Marketplace because it feels so predatory - we don't need microtransactions in a block game, nor do we need to be paywalling people's creativity. I do understand that I'm stupid and people want to make money off of the marketplace, but I feel like a donation approach is better. (and we seriously don't need a skibidi toilet marketplace addon)

As for the servers thing, yeah. It's not Mojang's fault that the servers are worse-moderated, but the combat needs serious help.
Also, the Hive isn't that bad, have you seen Lifeboat? Or Mineville, or Enchanted Dragons. Those last two cost money to be able to even enter.

The one upside of bedrock is the easy multiplayer - no paying for a server or dealing with LAN, you can just join friends (I get that Essentials exists for Java, but still).
4
harrymanjungle
11/11/2024 11:45 am
Level 1 : New Miner
if you use stuff like Radmin I think you don't even need to be on the same wifi for LAN.
1
McAlpake
11/09/2024 1:48 pm
He/Him • Level 22 : Expert Zombie Fisherman
Yes, i agree with your answer.
1
Team UNNAMED
11/09/2024 11:04 am
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Creeper
the only thing that *actually* sucks about bedrock edition is the loading times
you have to wait 2 minutes to even get TO the loading screen, and another 5 to get past THAT.
Also it takes 5 minutes to enter a world
4
McAlpake
11/09/2024 12:33 pm
He/Him • Level 22 : Expert Zombie Fisherman
yeah
1
Luke_303
12/27/2024 5:37 am
He/Him • Level 5 : Apprentice Artist
Ye it absulutly sucks. I played it long time ago ...
3
JKuantamechanic
12/27/2024 5:23 am
Level 14 : Journeyman Network Architect
Nah. It's actually superbly good! It stops players from falling off the world. Imagine if an ordinary player followed the number 1 (MUST DO!) rule of Minecraft, digging straight down, and just fell through the world, no beuno I say. That's why I always mine a good stash of bedrock for placing down at y=-100, so I don't meet such a fate.
3
Dronko fire blaster
12/07/2024 2:55 am
Level 51 : Grandmaster Dragonborn
I just call it bugrock now
3
magni12022
11/21/2024 5:01 pm
He/Him • Level 10 : Journeyman Cat
neither edition sucks, both are good in there own whey.
3
charzard123456789
11/13/2024 11:01 pm
Level 7 : Apprentice Farmer
I disagree because the bedrock playerbase is more tame than Java's
3
MrCage_
11/13/2024 7:49 pm
He/Him • Level 19 : Journeyman Blacksmith Taco
Sketchy marketplace 💀
3
Group of Allay and the vex
11/11/2024 6:42 pm
She/Her • Level 15 : Journeyman Princess
But I play in Bedrock so I disagree
3
MrJackUzzi
11/11/2024 2:52 pm
He/Him • Level 2 : Apprentice Artist
history
Here's some of my experience on (cracked) Bedock:
>be me

>played cracked Java for 3 years and Minecrat Classic 2 years prior

>friend tells me he found a way to actually hack Bedrock Free Trial

>check it out

>HOLY_CRABS_IT_WORKS.mp4

>play survival

>ok that sucks

>play with the dude who helped me

>find out he has a boyfriend (lol)

>he and his boyfriends bully me on the server

>leave

>talk to him 2 weeks later

>"yo let's play multiplayer survival"

>Hell_Yeah.mp4

>they all invited me late so they can have better gear and bully me again

>I find a glitch to duplicate notch apples (I have worse internet connection than Australia)

>tell my """friend""" I can trade half-stack for some netherite tools

>next day

>he tells the server owner (his boyfriend) that I am conspiring against him and I regularly backbite him

>blud enables cheats and starts interrogating me in an unlit dirt hole

>Execute GTFO Protocol

>Task failed

>they threaten to ban me

>Here. (hands over 10 N. Apples) This all I have! (Lie) [​Speech 75]
>they mock me and leave the server (I am the only one online now)

>I duplicate the 3 stacks of n. apples I have hidden and find a new place to hide my stash

>forget to enter the server for like 3 weeks

>they have converted the server to Java (how????) and installed plugins and mods (bruh)

>they somehow check my player inventory and find out I have 2 stacks of n. apples

>bruh_moment.mp4

>I join the server

>"Yo Jack want some librarians?"

>I head over to their base

>Learn what "Treason" means

>They temporarily disable keep-inventory and stole mah apples bruh 😭😭😭😭

>Respawn

>I return

>they mock me again

>"lol still stuck on iron mr. builder"

>I wait for them to leave again

>Head over to Casa d'Trash-Heap

>build a lag machine under their base (thank you SalC1 and the p2p server-busters!)

>wait for them to join

>the """friend""" joins (finally)

>he's working on their base again and is right above me

>quickly enable the lag-a-tron 2000 and GTFO

>You know what's would be really funny?

>The ""friend's house""" is like 1 km away from me so I can ride a bicycle to his humble abode for brotastic-fun-times™ 🥰🥰🥰

>I head over to his house

>lil' bro is confused as hell

>"I KNOW YOU DID SOMETING! WHY ISN'T THE SERVER WORKING!??!"

>whaddayamean.mp3

>The server actually crashes because his internet ain't that great either (Pakistan moment)

>I eat at his house as I watch his mother scold him for swearing at a guest lmao

>bro rages at me on discord and says "i lost all my gear bcuz of u" "i grinded for 3 weeks on fu-***ing pocket edition you fa-****"

>mission accomplished

>next day

>"Oooh Xbox app needs an update"

>Updates

>bruh my Cracked Bedrock free trial won't work anymore 😭😭😭💀

>visit my ""friend"" on discord

>I am blocked

  
  Welp, fellas I am playing to buy both Bedrock and Java on Blessed Friday sales. Is it worth it?
3
ohio920dagamer
11/13/2024 7:11 pm
He/Him • Level 26 : Expert Procrastinator
rip
1
EvasiveSpirit
11/11/2024 5:43 pm
Level 11 : Journeyman Network
I didn't read all of that but an attempt was made.
1
McAlpake
11/11/2024 3:54 pm
He/Him • Level 22 : Expert Zombie Fisherman
What
1
MasterCrash16
11/11/2024 8:43 am
Level 8 : Apprentice Miner
nope bedrock should stay theres multi player. dyeable water. and better armor stands plus microsoft isnt shuting minecraft down any time soon so delete this forum
3
ETTY
11/11/2024 2:36 pm
Level 1 : New Miner
1. dyable water isnt cool

2. Java has Servers + Mods that host single player worlds making bedrocks official World hosting useless

3. he aint finna delete this forum xD your no one important
4
subspace
12/06/2024 1:19 pm
He/Him • Level 7 : Apprentice Explorer
i would argue that being able to play with friends without having to host a whole server is convenient
1
McAlpake
11/11/2024 9:24 am
He/Him • Level 22 : Expert Zombie Fisherman
Nah I'm good
3
Jerrygames124
11/09/2024 12:38 pm
He/Him • Level 15 : Journeyman Sus Carrot
Bedrock isn't bad.
3
markl1zard
12/16/2024 9:44 am
It/It • Level 32 : Artisan Herobrine Herobrine
Many people hate minecraft bedrock...
(Well,bedrock editon are so convenient to play with friends)
2
subspace
11/19/2024 12:29 pm
He/Him • Level 7 : Apprentice Explorer
i dont think either one inherently sucks its just your outlook on them can be based on your starting or returning experience, like both of them have annoying bugs and hackers but a lot of people like either one, like i personally like both editions
2
Finnodile
11/11/2024 6:50 pm
Level 39 : Artisan Goblin Nerd
well both versions have cheaters, and skeletons suck in both versions ngl. It's a bit extreme to say it should shut down when it has good features such as crossplay, easy lans, two pages on books, more dyable stuff, more snapshots, HD and transparent skins, map making tools, education edition, longer reach, faster attacking, exclusive textures, and most importantly....
SPEED BRIDGING
2
Finnodile
11/11/2024 6:53 pm
Level 39 : Artisan Goblin Nerd
oh yeah, and the ability to /locate any structures you havent visited yet
2
harrymanjungle
11/11/2024 11:44 am
Level 1 : New Miner
No, bedrock doesn't suck. Hackers? Java has them too. Servers are worse but not close to being bad. Marketplace? Just download stuff online. Little complaints like off hand, doors not stopping drowning etc are downright stupid though they should be features. I saw someone complaining about loading times and I haven't had an issue with them on even a 2013 laptop. People worrying about Microsoft's effects on bedrock are silly, we've had player reporting for years and I don't know anyone that's been banned from Minecraft due to reporting and mod's/addons are not disappearing anytime soon. Though I agree with stuff like worse modding capabilities, lack of a good F3, not being able to change textures in world, worse resource packs, worse commands etc. Still, way too many people hate on bedrock, java can have similar simple multiplayer and can be played on PS4 and mobile through emulation (Mac and Linux too natively) to mimic Bedrock being on so many devices, but those aren't easy as it is with bedrock, I also prefer bedrock PvP though Java 1.9+ combat is fun. Both are great and give the Minecraft experience, saying one or the other suck is incredibly stupid. I only play bedrock because it's easier to crack lol. Also, I've found that bedrock actually runs worse as there aren't any performance mods and I also agree with wither, ender dragon, enderman, being disconnected when you close the window etc complaints. Yeah, overall Java is better but Bedrock is definitely not bad.
2
ETTY
11/11/2024 2:34 pm
Level 1 : New Miner
you forgot one thing. Java servers have BETTER Anticheats especially big servers like hypixel (Fun fact hypixel has a anticheat worth 1.5 Million Dollars xD)
2
harrymanjungle
11/21/2024 4:26 pm
Level 1 : New Miner
true that but I rarely see hackers on either platforms. More often it would be on bedrock tho.
1
harrymanjungle
11/11/2024 11:44 am
Level 1 : New Miner
tl;dr both good but Java is better
2
Jerrygames124
11/11/2024 1:06 pm
He/Him • Level 15 : Journeyman Sus Carrot
Minecraft itself said bedrock is better
1
McAlpake
11/13/2024 6:59 pm
He/Him • Level 22 : Expert Zombie Fisherman
its not, don't believe anything you hear
4

Welcome