FINISHED, Winners are:

First:
With a score of 49:
Neo!
And, he gets The Binding of Isaac, plus
(it is a Giwizard, or magical organ meat)

Second:
With a score of 46:
SharkBoi!
and his trophy:
(its Shawarm-bodies, or undead shawarma)

and Third (which was a tie, so I had the one that was posted before the other):
With a score of 45:
XDInsanity!
His trophy:
(Horrorganic, evil lettuce)

And, the rest are judged thus, in order of highest score to lowest:

(Please note, these are the combined totals of all three judges, and they were judged on the creativity and execution of the skin)

And to all the participants, a very special participation trophy:


(all trophies made by the amazing Hawkeye245)