Minecraft Blogs / Article

Asking For Help - Receiving Constructive Criticism

  • 835 views, 2 today
  • 22
  • 6
  • 60
Greytopher's Avatar Greytopher
Retired Moderator
Level 57 : Grandmaster Pig
1,010
Hello all, Greytopher here with another topic I'd like to talk about: denying criticism when you ask for it. Nothing is more annoying then someone asking for help, recieving it, then bashing on you about how you reportedly 'bashed on them'.
(Photo made by Dingousa! Check him out!)


So... you want help, or not?

Noobs. We're all one at some point, but when you're the Admin/member helping that one noob, it has GOT to be frustrating. But, when someone asks for a rating for their build (on creative servers), and you give them your wonderful building advice on how they could improve all they do is stare, rage, then leave. Not taking any advice you've given them, they've only got desperate needs, disappointment, or a firey rage of hate.

"Nao gray, hao com u dint prmte meh?" Well for starters, fix your grammar. It's hideous. Secondly, you've got to take the advice that's given to you! It's there for a reason, and use it to your advantage! I will explain some of this later, on how to give advice, and how you should respond with recieving it.

"bu bu bu..." I don't want to hear it! *looks away* All I want to see is you improving, and you becoming a better builder is my priority (I will include a blog later on how to make basic houses!). If you complain, I won't bother to help, only ignore you until the following day. Take the advice given to you, or you'll never improve.


Giving Advice - What to do

When giving advice to another player, there are certain guidlines you need to follow in order for them to understand your concept. Firstly, you've got to explain in detail! Saying things like "It needs work" then leaving, doesn't leave them any better since they've started. Saying things like "It needs some work, use more block variation. Logs go well with planks, so you could use those." Explaining what they could do always works, since it gives them ideas on what they could improve.

DON'T tell them they've done a good job, when you know they haven't. Telling them lies about how good they are is just in morale ways is wrong, and leaves them worse then before, thinking they've improved. I'm urging those who are moderators/admins to help players build (if on creative servers), since it's really the whole other aspect to the game.

Ignoring the situation doesn't help you or the player, either. The more you ignore the player asking for help, the more of a noob you look, and the more mad a player gets. You don't know the player, and you don't need to start flaming with him. The best you can do is give a quick look at what that player has to offer and who knows, maybe that person has the best build you've seen in a long time; or the best build you've ever seen.


Receiving Advice - What NOT to do

If you're asking for help, you better expect the worst. I know (from experience) that if you ask, and the person's hard on you but gives you advice on what to do, DON'T TAKE IT PERSONALLY! That's the last thing you want to do. If you take it personally, it will be harder to develop social skills to talk to people and (like I've said multiple times) receiving advice.

Being patient with the person who 'reviews' what you've made is key! The longer you wait, and the more flexible you are with that moderator/admin, they'll ease into reviewing your build. They won't be as tense as they will when they see someone screaming in chat "HEY ADMIN PLZ RATE MY BUILD!!!". It's more frustrating to see that in chat then anything else, so please, being patient and asking nicely can do wonders.

Lastly, when you receive advice, TAKE IT! I can't tell you how many times I've gotten building advice, and I went from making cities out of two block materials to making very detailed homes and cathedrals and making terraformed islands. I want you to improve, and the more advice you get from someone on how to make it look better, the better of a builder you will become. Trust me, I've grown as a builder SO MUCH over the past year and 9 months; it's really cool to see someone, especially yourself, improve.



This blog is brought to you by the Infini Garde. Let the quality in writing be presented in a fashionable manner.

That's all I have for this blog! If you liked it, please leave a diamond, favorite, and overall subscribe for more content by me!

Please do not repost this anywhere else on the web without my permission, thank you.

gmglpng

(Credit once again goes to Dingousa!)
Tags

Create an account or sign in to comment.

1
09/08/2012 3:25 pm
Level 6 : Apprentice Explorer
[]DirtBlock[]
[]DirtBlock[]'s Avatar
To me this blog seems a bit dumbed down and obvious compared to your others. Doesn't really give any advice to most people...
1
09/09/2012 9:40 pm
Level 5 : Apprentice Explorer
SwaggerHippo77
SwaggerHippo77's Avatar
You'd probably be surprised how many people don't know how to do this stuff. Soooooo many people rage about criticism when in fact, it's the best thing to get! You always should want to get better and if you realize what you're doing wrong than you can fix it and make it better.
1
09/06/2012 9:52 pm
Level 34 : Artisan Nether Knight
Tassadar12345
Tassadar12345's Avatar
thx im having lots of problems with mean people.
1
09/06/2012 10:11 pm
Level 57 : Grandmaster Pig
Greytopher
Greytopher's Avatar
Mhmm.
1
09/06/2012 8:20 pm
Level 4 : Apprentice Explorer
Fanferd71VOV
Fanferd71VOV's Avatar
Lol!! Niice...
1
09/06/2012 8:21 pm
Level 57 : Grandmaster Pig
Greytopher
Greytopher's Avatar
Indeed!
1
09/06/2012 8:14 pm
Level 26 : Expert Dragonborn
petersee
petersee's Avatar
Well written. I've been reading many of your blogs and they are all very interesting. You just got a sub. ^^
1
09/06/2012 8:15 pm
Level 57 : Grandmaster Pig
Greytopher
Greytopher's Avatar
I'm glad you like them. It makes me feel... warm inside when people like what I put out. Thank you!
1
09/06/2012 8:17 pm
Level 26 : Expert Dragonborn
petersee
petersee's Avatar
You're very welcome! Keep up the good job! Haha. Hopefully we'll see a 500 sub blog or 1000 sub special soon. xD
1
09/06/2012 8:20 pm
Level 57 : Grandmaster Pig
Greytopher
Greytopher's Avatar
That would be... mind-blowing.
Planet Minecraft

Website

© 2010 - 2024
www.planetminecraft.com

Welcome