1

200 Subscriber Skyscraper Build Contest [Results Posted]]

jduartemiller's Avatar jduartemiller1/20/14 1:27 pm
3/28/2014 8:21 pm
Snaves's Avatar Snaves
Results have been posted

Thank you all for participating. My next contest is live. You should check it out

Original Post
I want to thank you all for the support and encouragement that i have received these past several months. As a means to thank you, i would like to start up a contest. Inspired by Venom's build contest, i am putting on a build contest of my own. As you all can see from my submissions (33 of the 41 projects), i am rather fond of skyscrapers. And lately, as i am working extensively on that part of the city, that is a lot of what i have been building in minecraft. So, rather fittingly, i am putting on a skyscraper contest.

The term "skyscraper" was used first at the end of the nineteenth century when steel frame buildings began to be erected in major cities. The Home Insurance Building of Chicago is often coined as the first, being 42m (138 ft) tall originally, and had 10 floors. Since then, buildings have grown significantly taller, as by the 1930s, a few buildings had exceeded 350m, and a decade into the 21st century, one building had exceeded 800m, with another, currently under construction, to be 1000m. Skyscrapers are a feat of engineering, man's conquering of gravity, and an attempt to permanently claim a portion of the sky. As you see, i have a sort of romanticized view of skyscrapers.

All flowery wording aside, this contest is to build a skyscraper, and we will use the nineteenth century definition of a skyscraper: a building 42m or taller. These constructions can be anything that you wish and any style from 12th century gothic church spires to ultra-modern parametrically designed eco-towers of the future, and anything in between. The only thing is, it must be tall.

I don't want these to be massive, so i will lay down a building plot restriction of 100 x 100 for your building (this does not include landscaping). This will hopefully give you the freedom to build however much you need



Contest Rules
1. build must be no larger than 100 x 100 (excluding landscape), and must be 42m or taller
2. must be an original build and built solely by you, no collaboration efforts
3. must be a new build (no rehashing old builds. Any project with a submitted date before January 20th will be disqualified)
4. Allowed to use a texture pack (note, judging will be done using default)
5. Must have a non-edited,shader-less, image with your build (other images may include renders/modded screenshots, etc.)
6. One entry per person
7. Does not need to be furnished (but bonus points if it is)
8. Allowed to make time lapses/other videos but they will not help your score.
9. Must include reference material (images) if you are making a recreation (and list architect's name)
10. must include drawings/precedents (any research) for an original design (you will not be judged on these drawings, it is just nice to see how you think). if there are no drawings, judges may choose to deduct points
11. All builds must include a schematic and/or world save

Violation of any of these rules will result in disqualification



Judging
Your project will be judged on the following criteria:

Creativity/Originality (10 points)
You should try to push the boundaries of the design, what is unique. We don't want to see just a glass box. We want to see clever design ideas that really push what minecraft is capable of.

Quality of build (10 points)

Detail (10 points)

Concept (15 points)
We want to see that you put some thought into the design. What were you thinking when you built it, what was your intent with your design.? If you were making a recreation of a real world building, what was their design intent, what did you learn from it. A good idea is worth pursuing. You can present this in drawings or in writing.

Landscape (5 points)


Judges:
Jduartemiller
NinamanOfficial
GGJ16
MattuFIN
Pajak_z_sieci


Prizes
1st place: Gold pixel trophy, subscription from me, shout-out on my profile forever, diamond from all the judges, and a build request for my City project

2nd place: Silver pixel trophy, subscription from me, shout-out on my profile for a month, diamond from all the judges

3rd place: Bronze pixel trophy, subscription from me, diamond from me




Results
1. Eco Tower by CaptainMangar
214 points

2. Original Skyscraper by Snaves
208 points

3. Mica by Bramboss1
207 points

4. Vladir's Tower by ElectrickPickle
196 points

5. Hillside Heights by Jackleton
195 points

6. The Skyscraper of the Lone Island by Eagoy
186 points

7. Skyscraper #3 by Yowsky
172 points

8. Senlock Place by Qmans
144 points

9. SILP Mega Skyscraper by Creeper346421
140 points



Thank you for participating, have fun and best of luck.
Posted by jduartemiller's Avatar
jduartemiller
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
871

Create an account or sign in to comment.

81

1
03/28/2014 8:21 pm
Level 57 : Grandmaster Engineer
Snaves
Snaves's Avatar
Woo 2nd place! Congrats CaptainMangar and Bramboss1 on 1st and 3rd!
This was fun! It got my creativity flowing for more original buildings. I will look out for the next contest.
1
03/28/2014 5:51 pm
Level 33 : Artisan Nerd
LegoSpidermanFan
LegoSpidermanFan's Avatar
congrats
1
03/28/2014 3:23 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
Sure, Eagoy, I can give you my judging notes shortly, and any other judge who wishes to do the same may do so as well. I shall PM you.
1
03/28/2014 2:56 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
We have finished judging and these are the results:

1. Eco Tower by CaptainMangar
214 points

2. Original Skyscraper by Snaves
208 points

3. Mica by Bramboss1
207 points

4. Vladir's Tower by ElectrickPickle
196 points

5. Hillside Heights by Jackleton
195 points

6. The Skyscraper of the Lone Island by Eagoy
186 points

7. Skyscraper #3 by Yowsky
172 points

8. Senlock Place by Qmans
144 points

9. SILP Mega Skyscraper by Creeper346421
140 points

Great job everyone, and we hope that you will participate in my next contest a few months from now. Also, remember, here is the participation trophy for all contestants. Thank you all for your wonderful work.

1
03/28/2014 4:52 pm
Level 52 : Grandmaster Architect
Januarius
Januarius's Avatar
Woh, thanks, I am honored! I look forward to another contest like this!
1
03/28/2014 3:13 pm
Level 56 : Grandmaster Lava Rider
eagoy
eagoy's Avatar
Congrats to the winners!

@jduartemiller,
Count me in for a next contest (99% sure)
I keep an eye out for it, I mean quite some entries for an community challenge
and proper judging. That I find not often.

Oh and one question:
Could you put up the scores per judging criteria?
I am curious at what points I did well and what not.
And also to figure out how my gamble of a ''different'' style worked out.
1
03/27/2014 6:53 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
Judging has concluded, and the results are being checked. Everyone did a fantastic job, and we hope to have the results up tomorrow at the latest
1
03/20/2014 7:42 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
Judging is underway, we should have the results soon.
1
03/20/2014 11:04 am
Level 43 : Master Architect
Technicube
Technicube's Avatar
http://www.planetminecraft.com/project/ ... -of-glory/

This is the TechniCube entry. I know that this is late so if it's not considered I understand. Good luck to all!

-Liranbromberg (TechniCube)
1
03/20/2014 6:45 am
Level 34 : Artisan Architect
WagonEnthusiast
WagonEnthusiast's Avatar
I am deeply sorry I was unable to make the deadline. Large family troubles aroused which were obviously unforeseen. The server I had the build on, decided to do a host migration which lasted far longer than I expected (4 weeks). I look forward to participating in any future competition you wish to hold, and actually entering said competition. I will still be uploading the Skyscraper to my PMC page once completed. I wish the best of luck to all participants.

May the odds, be ever in your favour.

-EST
1
03/20/2014 3:00 am
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
Contest is now closed
1
03/20/2014 2:32 am
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
Only a half hour more. Make sure you post your link to the forum. Best of luck, everyone
1
03/19/2014 5:42 am
Level 14 : Journeyman Miner
anonpmc1495382
anonpmc1495382's Avatar
[deleted]
1
03/19/2014 2:23 am
Level 14 : Journeyman Miner
anonpmc1495382
anonpmc1495382's Avatar
[deleted]
1
03/18/2014 11:15 am
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
Okay, to be safe, that will be good to do. And, only 40 hours left to get your projects in. Best of luck everyone
1
03/17/2014 4:10 pm
Level 14 : Journeyman Miner
anonpmc1495382
anonpmc1495382's Avatar
[deleted]
1
03/17/2014 4:35 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
Current entries has been updated with this. The reason that the glass isn't showing up is probably because you are using stained glass, and the schemagic isn't updated to handle that yet. Give them time to update it, but it will take time. In the schematics themselves, it shouldn't be an issue
1
03/18/2014 1:46 am
Level 14 : Journeyman Miner
anonpmc1495382
anonpmc1495382's Avatar
[deleted]
1
03/17/2014 3:57 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
i have already extended this an extra four weeks, i'm sorry, but that was long enough. I do plan to do another contest. But, if you can hammer it out in a day (which is possible, i have done it a number of times with projects), try to enter it. You have until March 19th at 11:59 Pacific Standard Time (Day Light Savings Time - 7 GMT)
1
03/17/2014 3:49 pm
Level 18 : Journeyman Warrior
serdarminecraft
serdarminecraft's Avatar
Oh and please give me 1 more week please!
1
03/17/2014 3:48 pm
Level 18 : Journeyman Warrior
serdarminecraft
serdarminecraft's Avatar
İ was going to enter but its 17 march today and its night. im going to sleep after a few minutes and i cant make this in 1 day. İ have school, homework, etc.
1
03/17/2014 3:11 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
Only two more days to submit, best to hurry, and best of luck to everyone.
1
03/16/2014 2:40 am
Level 14 : Journeyman Miner
anonpmc1495382
anonpmc1495382's Avatar
[deleted]
1
03/16/2014 2:25 am
Level 14 : Journeyman Miner
anonpmc1495382
anonpmc1495382's Avatar
[deleted]
1
03/10/2014 4:23 pm
Level 31 : Artisan Architect
CaptainMangar
CaptainMangar's Avatar
Hey Guys,

Here is my Build

http://www.planetminecraft.com/project/ecotower/

Hope you like it.

CaptainMangar
1
03/09/2014 5:00 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
These drawings don't have to be precise, pretty, or even accurately represent the final product. It just has to show that you were thinking of a concept of some sort before you set off. It can be simple so long as it conveys a point.

Also, if drawing is really turning you away that much from entering, you could always try your hand at recreating a real world building. The only thing that you would have to do is some research into the design (main concept and intent of the architect, some reference images, and if you can find them, some formal or conceptual diagrams)
1
03/09/2014 4:18 pm
Level 57 : Grandmaster Fox
Foxy
Foxy's Avatar
10. must include drawings/precedents (any research) for an original design (you will not be judged on these drawings, it is just nice to see how you think). if there are no drawings, judges may choose to deduct points

This is making me not lean towards not participating since nearly everything I do buildingwise is pretty much spontaneous.
1
03/07/2014 5:14 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
I will be away from internet access for a while, so if you get your entry in after this weekend, i will not be able to update the current entries until the contest closes. Do not worry, you still have 12 more days to submit.
1
03/06/2014 3:10 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
Excellent. I look forward to your project.
1
03/05/2014 10:11 am
Level 1 : New Miner
bohunk
bohunk's Avatar
Bohunk join the game
1
03/05/2014 5:38 am
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
Only two more weeks. Can't wait to see everyone's projects.
1
03/01/2014 3:30 pm
Level 39 : Artisan Bunny
OTB
OTB's Avatar
mkay... I guess I can buil it in 1.8 using the CMDS but i'll use blocks that are 1.7.5 compatible
1
03/01/2014 10:58 am
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
i would not have access to view it. 1.7.4 would be preferable.

* Revise: Just realized that 1.7.5 came out for download, and is the current version. Anything not compatible with this or earlier versions and if it cannot be viewed, it will not receive scores. Any features that do not work in these versions will also not contribute to the score.
1
03/01/2014 10:10 am
Level 39 : Artisan Bunny
OTB
OTB's Avatar
one question what if we're building in 1.8 alpha? can that still be submitted?
1
03/01/2014 9:55 am
Level 39 : Artisan Bunny
OTB
OTB's Avatar
oh wow 18 days i have enough time XD
1
03/01/2014 9:38 am
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
I have some ideas for a future one, but if you can knock one out in the next 18 days, you can still be entered
1
03/01/2014 8:53 am
Level 39 : Artisan Bunny
OTB
OTB's Avatar
I guess i came late to the party.... Will there be another competition like this or not?
because I enjoy building design and what not so maybe next time if there is a next time
1
02/28/2014 3:58 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
haha, well, you have a little time. I look forward to seeing it
1
02/28/2014 2:34 pm
Level 45 : Master Architect
CrankerMan
CrankerMan's Avatar
I might have my entry finished this weekend...
depends on how good the elder scrolls beta will be
1
02/27/2014 12:21 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
We have less than three weeks left to get your entry in. Looking forward to all of your builds.
1
02/24/2014 5:29 am
Level 1 : New Crafter
Uniquewarrior
Uniquewarrior's Avatar
Definitely going to enter, I will post the project link when done
1
02/23/2014 4:25 pm
Level 17 : Journeyman Pony
Aaroncool
Aaroncool's Avatar
Quick update:
Built the skyscraper. It isn't anything amazing but I quite like it.
I'm just waiting on the owner to send me the schematic file, so I should have by tonight/tomorrow.
1
02/23/2014 10:11 am
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
As long as we can see it, that is fine.

Rules:
"11. All builds must include a schematic and/or world save"

Having one or the other is good, having both would be better, but i believe all the judges have the capability to view schematic files
1
02/23/2014 9:57 am
Level 17 : Journeyman Pony
Aaroncool
Aaroncool's Avatar
Is it ok if I build it on a server then get the .schematic file for it? My singleplayer world got deleted so I'll have to begin again but at least I have no more issues with my .bin folder anymore.
1
02/23/2014 9:17 am
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
if you win one, you should see the bronze, silver, and gold trophies. I modeled them after my Spires project
1
02/23/2014 9:02 am
Level 45 : Master Architect
CrankerMan
CrankerMan's Avatar
omg you really want people to participate! That trophy is awesome!
1
02/23/2014 8:50 am
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
Just finished the pixel trophies. Here is the trophy for the participants
1
02/22/2014 4:51 pm
Level 33 : Artisan Pixel Painter
Pig Republic
Pig Republic's Avatar
I might join
1
02/21/2014 5:03 pm
Level 67 : High Grandmaster Architect
jduartemiller
jduartemiller's Avatar
That's okay, you still have time to get it in. Deadline is March 19th at 11:59pm PST.
1
02/21/2014 4:53 pm
Level 17 : Journeyman Pony
Aaroncool
Aaroncool's Avatar
I started my skyscraper a few hours ago, it's taking me a while because of issues with my .bin folder but I'm making progress ;P
Planet Minecraft

Website

© 2010 - 2024
www.planetminecraft.com

Welcome