tater's is better

Bump! Last day to vote

bump

[deleted]

I like the first one more.

allergys is cool, but taters looks more like the picture

I like Allergy's shading and colors, but he missed some very key features of the dragon.

Tater's is more accurate to the character and uses some cool hat layer tricks.

Both skins look great.. but I'll haveta vote for tater.

The shading on Allergy's skin's arms and legs doesn't transition well from each side, leaving weird colours that shouldn't be close to each other near the sides. (Dark shades next to really bright shades).

Annnd, tater's shading is a bit messy, but I feel it captured the character better.

Hard choice,but i'm gonna have to say Allergy's.

This is a tough one, but I have to go with Tater's. Allergy's skin is cleaner, but Tater's is more detailed and accurate to the picture.

Its gonna be close GG Allergy

Thanx for everyones feedback and votes

Dang this is hard. I'm going to have to go with Tater's skin. I like the 3D stuff on it.
Sorry allergy.

Tater's has too much detail (too much purple smoke, looks cluttered)

Allergy's has too little (no eyes?)

I do think allergy's looks cooler though.

although taterman's represents the reference more, i like the shading and design on allergy's a bit better.

Both are awesome. Allergy's palette seems better and the skin is better shaded, but Tater's is more accurate and my vote goes for him. Sorry Allergy.

Going with allergy, taters just looks sorta messy to me.

I like Allergy's skin a bit better, but looking at what you had to recreate I feel as if Tater's skin was more accurate, and as the skin battle was about recreating a character into a skin, I think I'll end up voting Tater.

Oh gosh, this is hard. Both skins are incredible, but I'm going to go with taterman's, as I prefer his palette c: