Does it work with Optifine?

When I tried to add it to my texture pack folder it said error copying file

I don't use the honey bottle and like the Pumpkin Pie option, I use an Anvil to rename them to "Moo-Pop". I thought this recipe may be cool to use and Hermitcraft-worthy.

1 of each & their contribution to the formula:
Honey Bottle - Bottle & Sugar
Milk Bucket - Milk (obviously)
Sweet Berries - Flavor & Color
Red Mushroom - Nutrition
Brown Mushroom - Nutrition
Redstone - Health replenishment & Carbonization
Ice - Warm pop sucks

Here's a recipe file if you want to add it to your world, I know the Milk does not stack. Hermitcraft never does anything easy and I thought this would be a fitting setup.

Moo-Pop Recipe.json (Google Drive Download Link)

what does it replace again?