I've kind of figured it out, im going to use 5 CMD blocks, using /give @a[score_Kills=5,score_Kills_min=5] 264 5 0 {ench:[{id:34,lvl:9}],display:{Name:Glory Token,Lore:[Redeem at Glory Quartermaster for gear!]}} and so on down to 0 recieving one token. I'm doing this by changing min and max values to 4,3,2,1 and min for 1 be 0, so all players recieve at least ONE token. This seems to be working, im going to repeat this process for the Honor Tokens as well