Am I A Good Builder?

Pretty nice!



-Constructive Criticism-

The walls could use more depth and detailing, with the walls on the second floor (or roof level) they are very flat and plain, try adding some designs and more shape to it. Overall, it's pretty good though!

-iRoller

My review: Your colors are okay, but your roofs lack detail, and your builds lack depth. Other than that, you seem to be going in the right track. Try experimenting with complex wall patterns. Also, watch some voxelsniper tutorials to get better at voxeling.

Really like it

you might want to ask for constructive criticism rather than say something as blanketty as "am i a good builder" because it can be interpreted as, y'know, a tad egocentric
especially with the bump

Bump

Looks fine, but its a very common building style, so try and make it more original.

It's pretty bad

My comment below.

It's not bad but like people have said its not very original. I can't really judge your building skills from 1 picture.

*cough* *cough*Bump*cough* *cough*

I think it's quite good. I generaly don't do much medieval though.

Not to shaby i must say myself!

For some inspiration, here's my grandfather's old Tudor-style house (which he sold several years ago):

It's really good. Try adding a little more detail on the attic wall. It looks a little bland and flat as it is.

I am having such a hard time creating my own style. I really like the way that the Tudor style looks and gives me a hard time changing styles. ;-;

I'm no build expert, but it does looks pretty good to me.

I would consider you a ok-good builder. I like your advance shapes in the house, and keeping in mind you aimed for realism, I would say not bad. Maybe you would like your windows to be more accessible, like add a pedestal so that people have a actual purpose for that window there, not just for viewing. Throw in a bit of depth, but don't over do the depth, because it would get rid of the implied shape and support that a house needs to fulfill the realism criteria

Don't listen to what people say about depth, it just makes the building look cluttered. Houses in real life don't really have depth, not even medieval houses.

Anyway, it's a good house, but you should do something with that huge attic space. Maybe an extra floor or something.

Also, this house style is called Tudor Style, not "Medieval".

Could you build my server spawn please?

I know you got lot of opinions already, but I hope you still mind checking on some more...

As many people said, it's nothing special/ original. I agree with that, but I believe you picked the right decision to make it unspecial. At the start, just copy other builds, recreate them, add few more details you want to change etc. With experience of that you will get a right feeling what's good. That way you'll get even better.
I advise you only that you should start making scenarios/ story to your builds. Honestly, when I look at your build, I tell to myself: nice build, just right big, just right details, good pick of details, usable,... but something still missing. Who live in that house? Elves, humans, dwarfs, normal villager? Miner or fighter? Where is that building placed, in the mountains or plains, which biome? I simply can't decide.

Without being that solved, build will be classic and nice. But with story you'll make people remember your build.

Looks alright but your need to add more detail and depth

as everyone else is saying: you are above average with great potential. I would love to see some builds from you that are a bit more original! They would be great! I have subbed to you in hopes to see some of that potential skill male something great! Plus I helped ya blame Paril

Its good, but not the most appealing. (Height wise)

I like the style. And the roofs? Just lovely. Though, maybe you can experiment a bit more with the lighting?

Good job, though!

nice build!

You're above average, though you could use some depth tutoring. I'd be happy to help you in that respect.

YEah you seem to know what you build! Only thing I'd recommend is that you could fit in some extra detail in the empty wool area

Its good, but as a few other people have said, not original at all. Overall, I would say your a good builder unless you just looked at google images and copied it...

I would say above average new builders. It is impossible to judge your building technique from only one small medieval building, especially as medieval building is often seen as one of the easiest building styles to execute in minecraft. Maybe post some pictures of some other builds, but building in general should just be fun, don't compare yourself with others!

philpres2I just built this midieval style building today and wondered if I would be considered as a "good" builder.

Click to reveal

http://imgur.com/H8c1QEN

Looks alright

I like it, you definitely build better than me

Yes. Could be much greater though.

Pssssttt, I know it's an opinion. Also, I'v just started building again so I still need to create my own style.

I like this bro!! Pls join in FP!
It's a good building team with friendly staff.
Link for application:
build-team-recruitment-t410836.html

I like the style and block choice. Good job!