Gotta go with Fred on this one.

Allergy's use of colors didn't hurt my eyes as much as Fred's did, but the purple unshaded area with the shaded gold thing on Allergy's samurai skin didn't blend well, which led me to voting for Fred's Shovel Knight skin.

Good luck to both of you!

Both of them were really good and I wish I could vote for both. But at the end I had to choose Fred's shovel knight
Vote is...
Fred's Shovel Knight!

fredrick has my vote

PureNerdAllergy, Why didn't you use more colors? And there's random red and gold pixels and like others have said before me, all the purple comes off as lazy. Excuse me if I sound harsh, but this skin just isn't good and I know you can make better skins than that.

I just made a better version, but I'm not going to update it until after the poll, since I made it after the deadline. I gave up with the green too fast. I literally spent 10 minutes, and got rid of most of the dark purple crap.

I'm pretty sad I didn't add it before the deadline.

Allergy, Why didn't you use more colors? And there's random red and gold pixels and like others have said before me, all the purple comes off as lazy. Excuse me if I sound harsh, but this skin just isn't good and I know you can make better skins than that.

Fred, the back is especially nice, and although the palette was hard to work with, you pulled off the character and used the colors the best you could.
As you can probably guess, I'm voting for Fred

Allergy boi use the other colors .-.

Fred's color mixing just hurts my eyes but has a decent amount of detail.
Allergy's skin seems unfinished to me but it doesn't burn my eyes.

No clue, will have to decide later I guess.

First off, we all know how fond Allergy is of Samurai skins and how many of them he has made in the past... *sigh* Also, I agree with Pikamoar; the unshaded purple areas on Allergy's skin left quite a bit to be desired, especially in contrast with his shading on the armour.

Fred's skin was decidedly creative in both his reference and shading; I especially loved his mix of colours.

All things considered, my vote is with Fred, but best of luck to both contestants.

The large splotches of unshaded purple on Allergy's just screamed laziness to me.

Fred.

I think we need to have an intervention about all your samurai skins

Both are very good, but I guess that Fred's skin looks better and the idea is also excellent. Sorry, Allergy. Your skin was also wonderful, but I feel it is incomplete.
Good luck you both

Behind you all the way samurai

( '-')7

Oh shoot! I was going Samurai and I really wanted to see it win but Fred has won my vote!

I love Allergy and all his samurai, but the shading on his seemed a little flat compared to Fred's gorgeous highlights, so I voted for the shovel knight. But honestly, I'd be okay if either of these skins won.

Fred

As much as I love samurai, I think Fredwardo has better skin execution

vote goes to Fred

SAMURAI POWER

Samurai all the way