2

Bedrock or java?

Dan_chuckles_69 6/5/24 1:33 pm
336
7/22/2024 10:20 am
if you had to chose bedrock or java what would it be me would be 100% java what bout you cuz I am wondering java or bedrock
Posted by
Dan_chuckles_69
Level 3 : Apprentice Miner
0

  Have something to say?

JoinSign in

14

Graycreature121
07/22/2024 10:20 am
Level 13 : Journeyman Explorer
They are both good in different ways, but because I've played on bedrock all my life I'm gonna say bedrock.
1
Alex2012MC
07/05/2024 6:00 am
He/Him • Level 30 : Artisan Zombie Architect
java
3
Cornbread_Alphanumeric
06/11/2024 3:14 am
She/They • Level 53 : Grandmaster Miner uwu
hmm.... there would be a lot of factors if i had to pick only one, but i'd probably go with bedrock. java edition's lack of controller support basically makes this no contest.
1
TheShadyy
06/11/2024 1:13 am
He/Him • Level 31 : Artisan Nerd Artist
should make it a poll
1
ScotsMiser
06/11/2024 1:30 am
Level 70 : Legendary Miner
Been done [​several times]
1
TheShadyy
06/11/2024 1:34 am
He/Him • Level 31 : Artisan Nerd Artist
that is true but like this guy didn't, fair point though
2
YoItsChuckie
06/11/2024 1:04 am
He/Him • Level 11 : Journeyman Artist
Neither, they're both riddled with spaghetti code, lag issues, and infested with suspicious predatory Human Beings, so it's a tie.
1
TheRedDemon
06/05/2024 7:20 pm
He/Him • Level 31 : Artisan Procrastinator Procrastinator
history
i like both and i prefer both
1
ScotsMiser
06/05/2024 7:01 pm
Level 70 : Legendary Miner
Java
► where I started and BR has never come close to being good enough I'd be inclined to unlearn and relearn. (Which is not to say this would apply to someone starting out)

► fewer conssessions to infants (of all ages)

► [somewhat] less involvement in day-to-day play by MS/Mj (no realms, no marketplace, no special approved servers, etc)

Java is the original and therefore the standard by which things should work.
Particularly true for java redstone: while there are some features from BR I can see importing (like an additional form of various containers that is moveable) changes should be bringing the version adapted to the limits of other platforms [BR] into line with the original.
2
TheShadyy
06/11/2024 1:14 am
He/Him • Level 31 : Artisan Nerd Artist
"(like an additional form of various containers that is moveable)" *cough *cough* moveable tile entities *cough*
2
ScotsMiser
06/11/2024 1:29 am
Level 70 : Legendary Miner
Pre-zac-tilly
"…while there are some features from BR I can see importing (like an additional form of various containers that is moveable) " [​emphasis added]

Note that this would also involve adding the immovable versions to BR to retain parity. [​The immobile versions can be quite useful as well.]
3
TheShadyy
06/11/2024 1:34 am
He/Him • Level 31 : Artisan Nerd Artist
true
2
oliviobobby
06/05/2024 1:42 pm
Level 58 : Grandmaster Architect Cat
bedrock - it is what i grew up on

(after legacy edition)
1
Dan_chuckles_69
06/05/2024 2:46 pm
Level 3 : Apprentice Miner
ty for feeback
2

Welcome