Which server idea sounds better?

As long as it's unique people will join
if you want alot of players i suggest the second one
the first one will get boring just after a while.

Squishy LemonRight now I'm thinking either an apocalyptic adventure server where you complete quests, rank up, and kill nazis. *It's very influenced from Wolfenstein: The New Order.*

OR

A free-roam PvP sandbox-like world that is based off of Saints Row III, in the idea that instead of factions, there are gangs that you can join and battle the other gangs, gain respect from other gangs, and rank up amongst your gang.

Tbh it's a hard choice but I would say you should kind of mix the two into something bigger! Think big and original! Anyways, also killing "nazis" is kind of a religious sort of thing, I guess, so I think, although, you may want to base it mostly on Wolfenstein, I think you should just change the name of the enemies you kill... Anyways, yea... so just try combining both ideas maybe but if you can't i'd go for Saints Row/GTA.

Id join the first one

Also I'm open to helpful criticism or other ideas