forum Forumsplay_arrow Minecraft fiber_manual_record Discussion

1

Worldedit or MC-Edit?

1 emerald34 replies1,086 views
created 09/15/2013 12:17 am by iltkamil
last reply 10/01/2013 4:18 pm
So me and some friends are debating what we like best. MC-Edit or Worldedit. I personally like MC-Edit. I find it cleaner and more efficient. But I will use worldedit I cant use mc-edit.
Posted by avatar
iltkamil
Level 32 : Artisan Architect
70

34 replies

1
09/30/2013 10:53 pm
Level 35 : Artisan Turtle
ryancat101
avatar
Depends what your doing
1
09/30/2013 10:45 pm
Level 29 : Expert Engineer
socksmusicalcat
avatar
I'd use MCEdit, but I'm too lazy, and I already know all the commands for WorldEdit, so I do pretty much everything in that unless it involves copy/pasting something that I know will end up giving my server an out of memory error if I try it with WE.
1
09/30/2013 10:29 pm
Level 22 : Expert Network
SoyMonkey
avatar
its kinda hard to say because they do completely different things mostly MC-Edit is better in my opinion because you can do a lot more with it like filters spawners and all that The BEST adventure maps are made with MC-Edit filters and spawners while WorldEdit is just terrain editing
1
10/01/2013 4:18 pm
Level 32 : Artisan Architect
iltkamil
avatar
I agree. Most adventure maps are edited with MC-edit then worldedit.
1
09/30/2013 10:19 pm
Level 47 : Master Blob
icedragon926
avatar
They are 2 different things...
1
09/30/2013 10:08 pm
Level 27 : Expert Dragon
SoraSatoshi
avatar
Using WorldEdit and MC-Edit is the best thing to do since they both have their pros and cons. Also if you don't have this http://www.planetminecraft.com/mod/build-commands/ for WorldEdit you are missing out.

Also I think that WorldEdit is much more powerful that VoxelSniper.
1
09/30/2013 10:16 pm
Level 32 : Artisan Architect
iltkamil
avatar
I was actually looking at inHaze's mod but I did not now if it still worked for 1.6.4 servers so I can out it on mine.
1
09/30/2013 10:19 pm
Level 27 : Expert Dragon
SoraSatoshi
avatar
I haven't tried it since my server is still on 1.6.2 but I think it should still work.
1
09/27/2013 2:33 pm
Level 33 : Artisan Pirate
Chips
avatar
I prefer MCEdit a lot more actually. I never got used to the commands and confusion of WorldEdit, even if MCEdit isn't as advanced it's a lot easier for newcomers and lazy people who hate to learn things like me
1
09/30/2013 9:59 pm
Level 32 : Artisan Architect
iltkamil
avatar
Same! Before I learned worldedit i used mcedit because it was easier to learn and personally for me its a lot neater.
1
09/18/2013 7:20 pm
Level 25 : Expert Dragonborn
ItsGoldFun
avatar
Worldedit is my favorite because it's much more quicker. MCEdit takes forever to do stuff...

Worldedit is so much more simpler, when MCEdit is like "nope cant do that, nope cant do that either".

So basically, I choose Worldedit.
1
09/26/2013 4:10 pm
Level 21 : Expert Modder
Creeper_Modder
avatar
But you cant make structure spawners in worldedit...
1
09/26/2013 4:05 pm
Level 32 : Artisan Architect
iltkamil
avatar
I can totally relate to that.
1
09/18/2013 7:15 pm
Level 20 : Expert Engineer
BonyRaptor101
avatar
MCEdit is my personal favorite. Sure, World Edit is quicker since you never actually have to leave game, but MCEdit can just do so much more.
And yes, I've used both.
1
09/15/2013 1:02 pm
Level 32 : Artisan Architect
iltkamil
avatar
Well I just wanted to see who liked what. I left worldpaint out because thats mostly for creating custom worlds and terra forming. I've never heard of world machine. And voxelsniper is terra forming.
1
09/18/2013 7:07 pm
Level 17 : Journeyman Narwhal
DrForrestera
avatar
But WE Terra forms as well.

I still say WE has the most agility in all fields. I have never tried painter, I would like to though.
1
09/15/2013 12:40 pm
Level 49 : Master Blob
Speedy
avatar
This thread doesn't make any sense as they are two completely different things.

Worldedit is mainly professionally used to terraform and easily set large structures.

MCEdit is mainly professionally used for mapmakers to achieve things that are impossible in the real game.
1
09/15/2013 12:32 pm
Level 41 : Master Pokemon
Jacob Rigoberto
avatar
MCEdit can with some filters do all World Edit can do. MCEdit of course.
1
09/15/2013 12:21 pm
Level 4 : Apprentice Crafter
Ace Ginger
avatar
World Edit
is for easing edits that are done in the game. It makes replacing blocks easier, growing trees easy, and doing small things that are annoying but generally feasible without the plugin.

McEdit
is for copying and pasting (as far as I know World Edit cannot), and for completing tasks that are so large that they are nearly impossible to do in game. It also is for using Seth Bling's filters, and for mass conversions of blocks. Here is an example of an McEdit Map I made:
http://www.planetminecraft.com/project/ ... nture-map/

World Painter
seems to have been forgotten in this post, but is actually my personal favorite because it changes terrain so drastically. It is for generating beautiful terrain from scratch with some added features like trees and snow, or for editing an existing map to be more beautiful. World Edit focuses on easing repetitive tasks, McEdit allows copy paste and enabling completion of massive tasks, and World Painter is the enviornment controller; the program to use before making your epic castle.

Voxel Sniper and World Machine
are not the same thing, but I don't know anything about them. They are there though.
1
09/15/2013 12:41 pm
Level 49 : Master Blob
Speedy
avatar
Worldedit can copy and paste.
1
09/15/2013 10:29 am
Level 32 : Artisan Architect
iltkamil
avatar
Everyone says Worldedit and MC-Edit are totally different things. I don't see it. They do most of the same things but have different options. I mostly use MC-Edit for schematics and finding the middle of a area. Or just to flatten land etc.
1
09/15/2013 1:56 am
Level 17 : Journeyman Narwhal
DrForrestera
avatar
I like WorldEdit better then voxel. But mcedit and WE are very different, Overall I like WE better.
1
09/15/2013 1:29 am
Level 40 : Master Cake
aman207
avatar
I like them both.

There is no way that I can export a schematic from a server using world edit. Not that good.
1
09/15/2013 1:35 am
Level 46 : Master Technomancer
ThatsMyPickaxe
avatar
That too, I've tried to load schems with W.E., it wasn't very fun.
1
09/15/2013 1:49 am
Level 40 : Master Cake
aman207
avatar
I can't even copy and paste anything. It goes all over the place. Very hard to get it in the right spot.
1
09/15/2013 1:20 am
Level 56 : Grandmaster Programmer
sycoinc
avatar
You forgot VoxelSniper

But i use both World Edit and VoxelSniper on my server, depends on the need
1
09/15/2013 12:44 am
Level 34 : Artisan Ninja
TheBoss0260
avatar
swimmer1929They're 2 entirely different things. WorldEdit is a plugin that you can use on a server to quickly edit blocks, MC-Edit just allows you to edit maps.

True dat
1
09/15/2013 12:38 am
Level 22 : Expert Engineer
Koala_Steamed
avatar
World edit all the way xD

I just use it for building large redstone mechanisms. Mostly use it for the copy paste as well as colour coding blocks to make things easier to see. I have a lot of commands set with key binds, which makes things a lot faster.

To edit nbtags i use an ingame nbtediter so i never have to leave the game
1
09/15/2013 12:34 am
Level 64 : High Grandmaster Hero
sed11
avatar
I like to use MCEdit when using filters such as SethBling's or trying to build quickly and also importing schematics.
I like to use WorldEdit if I feel like working on a map on my own home-run server with 1 or 2 slots only and just use it to build quickly in-game, although I don't do this as much.

(I chose MCEdit)
1
09/15/2013 12:31 am
Level 46 : Master Technomancer
ThatsMyPickaxe
avatar
I prefer worldedit, if i need to flatten an area of land, I can just do //replace air and then //replace [whatever block the ground is] [what i want]. If i use mcedit, I have to close the world, make a bunch of awkward selections, then edit the blocks.

In short, i find Worldedit much more convenient.

*I will use mcedit if I want to use sethbling's filters.
1
09/15/2013 12:23 am
Level 20 : Expert Toast
Unnatural
avatar
Well, why not both, I love worldedit, cause I can see the effects ingame, and it has lots more features then MCedit, but it has a tendency to crash servers when you world edit a lot, so MCedit is better for big stuffs.
1
09/15/2013 12:20 am
Level 39 : Artisan Taco
Swimmer1929
avatar
They're 2 entirely different things. WorldEdit is a plugin that you can use on a server to quickly edit blocks, MC-Edit just allows you to edit maps and is too cumbersome in my opinion.
1
09/15/2013 12:39 am
Level 57 : Grandmaster Geek
OneSidedBattle
avatar
Worldedit's not just a plugin for servers. There are other programs that support it like SPC.
1
09/15/2013 12:21 am
Level 22 : Expert Pokemon
XZW72
avatar
That is EXACTLY what I was going to say XD

Planet Minecraft

Browse

Site

© 2010 - 2019
planetminecraft.com

Welcome