For some reason, mods never get on the popular reel on the home page. I've seen skins with under 20 views make the popular reel on the home page, but mods with over 10,000 views are only on the popular reel for mods.
I think a solution would be if you had to type a reason for why you downvoted, but remain anonymous. The author of the submission would be able to see the reason, and can report it if the reason isn't good (something like "this project sucks"), and a moderator can look at it and decide whether or not to remove it. That way trolls can't downvote without reason, and people aren't afraid to give downvotes if they actually have constructive criticism.