1
Should I make this pack?
I've asked people if I should make a shaded version of my texturepack. since I didn't get any answers in the comments I'm asking it here again.
Should I make a shaded (that basicaslly means good looking) version of this texturepack I made?
http://www.planetminecraft.com/texture_pack/ragdoll-adventure/
Here is what stone an cobblestone might look like in the shaded version:

Even if most people vote no I might still make it, I just want to know what you think of this.
If you vote, please also say why you voted that.
Should I make a shaded (that basicaslly means good looking) version of this texturepack I made?
http://www.planetminecraft.com/texture_pack/ragdoll-adventure/
Here is what stone an cobblestone might look like in the shaded version:
Click to reveal

Even if most people vote no I might still make it, I just want to know what you think of this.
If you vote, please also say why you voted that.
11
Looks great
The grass is a solid, bright green color
Also, it ends really abruptly when it changes into dirt.
Also, it ends really abruptly when it changes into dirt.
Haha This texure pack reminds me when I was a kid. But I say dont make it shaded because its already good looking... well in my eyes its good but if you add shade to that well... yea.
I'm not changing the original, I'm thinking of making a second version of the pack that is shaded. I would still update the original for the latest minecraft updates.
Dirt Texture Looks Like Grass on a Rock and Simply Made
50/50
50/50
I'm sorry but I can't really tell if you're being sarcastic or not.
TheBrickCoderJohnanaterIt was supposed to look derpy and ugly but not glichy, the pack I was thinking of making would be still derpy but not as ugly.
I think it would look more ugly shaded.
This is wierd, when I asked people if they liked my pack they said it needed shading and when I ask people now they say the opposite. I know you're not the same people but it's still wierd.
here is the old thread I was talking about: http://www.planetminecraft.com/forums/what-you-think-resource-pack-t295414.html
Don't reply to it, that would count as necroposting and that's against the rules.
I made a dirt and grass texture, what do you think of these?
Click to reveal

JohnanaterIt was supposed to look derpy and ugly but not glichy, the pack I was thinking of making would be still derpy but not as ugly.
I think it would look more ugly shaded.
make a HSV and bump map one
shaded anything look horrible
shaded anything look horrible
It looks good how it is already.
It was supposed to look derpy and ugly but not glichy, the pack I was thinking of making would be still derpy but not as ugly.
I could make a bump map addon I have played around with bump mapping a little bit. What do you mean with HSV?
rupertmake a HSV and bump map one
shaded anything look horrible
I could make a bump map addon I have played around with bump mapping a little bit. What do you mean with HSV?
