[yt]www.youtube.com/watch?v=20UhjXpFX_c[/yt]

Apologies if that works I just couldn't stop myself.

You both made really good skins c: both unique to the way that YOU shade/style- I don't see anything wrong with that ^_^b

I lost, oh well haha. Good battle Kefka good look with the rest of the season!

Kefka

taterman88

Kefka
I see nothing wrong with using the same styles, it would be hard to find a skinner that doesn't.

Not that hard. What about tater?

shhhhh.....your ruining my argument.

Well that wasnt my intention. If I could I would like to speak boldly for a moment. IMO this nonsense with the "blue skin" is pretty ridiculous. That particular blue skin is part of a set of 3 which are all very similar and it's actually the least popular of the three. The most popular is nearing 30,000 downloads and 600 diamonds. Collectively that set has well over 100,000 views. It's not like Kefka stole that particular style, he developed it with hard work, and it is a winning formula. I don't think it looks like a recolor at all and I'm surprised anyone even mentioned that. No offence to uPro or my rosstafarian brother Zitzabis as I have a lot of respect for them and they are both amazing artists, but neither of them are in the same league as Kefka, nor am I, as few are. The numbers alone speak for themselves. I'm not idolizing him. He is just a man and KnobleKnives would kick his ass with his brilliant use of color and halucid would smoke him and Roobus would have a good shot with his crazy illusion designs and use of hat layer, but busting out pictures of his older super successful skins seems ridiculous.

Really not trying to be disrespectful. I love you guys. Just stating my opinion.

Kefka

taterman88

Kefka
I see nothing wrong with using the same styles, it would be hard to find a skinner that doesn't.

Not that hard. What about tater?

shhhhh.....your ruining my argument.

Oh, and don't forget PureNerd.

taterman88

Kefka
I see nothing wrong with using the same styles, it would be hard to find a skinner that doesn't.

Not that hard. What about tater?

shhhhh.....your ruining my argument.

Kefka
I see nothing wrong with using the same styles, it would be hard to find a skinner that doesn't.

Not that hard. What about tater?

Kefka
Anyone that compares these two skins in 3d can clearly see that they are in no way recolors...they both happen to be made by the same skinner that uses this style.

I agree with Kefka on this one.

KefkaYeah, but the whole "same idea" thing doesn't make sense either, uPro has done two other boxer skins before this one. Isn't that the same idea that he has done before too?

uPro's boxer idea has been used multiple times, I agree. But I'm not saying a repeat is a bad thing! A wise user once said to me:

AnonymousI would rather give a diamond to a unique skin

Sadly, I didn't feel that yours was overly unique. Just a matter of opinion.

pikamoar
The difference is, you were using almost the same design/layout of the skin, whereas uPro was using the same shading. So, we're talking about two different things here. Styles and shading are different, yet you're treating them like the same thing.
Observe below. Both use the same shading, but are very different in design:
Whereas, your skins use very similar layouts, almost as if they're recolors of a single skin.

Anyone that compares these two skins in 3d can clearly see that they are in no way recolors...they both happen to be made by the same skinner that uses this style.

Kefka: I like the skin, it looks good, but I'm not a fan of it.
If I can be blunt, it's just gradient shading with a really good palette. While this doesn't mean it looks bad, it just...doesn't have that flare that uPros has.

I prefer uPros because of that shading pattern; it isn't "well if I put a dark color here, the next one should go above/beside it" . A decent amount of thought had to be put into "well where do I put the highlight?" . It's quirky, it's different and is interesting.

PureNerd

Pikamoar

PureNerd
Don't do that, vote for which ever one you like better, Don't pitty the losing side because the whole point of this poll is to decide which is better

Only reason i would've was because i liked both equally. But I have decided, but i'm going to keep my vote private

If you like them both equally and can't decided don't vote,
and why keep your vote a secret? No ones gonna judge you for it, besides I already know who you voted for so if it's because you think I'll disagree because of why you made the choice, than I assure you, I won't. Your vote is your vote

Its just that i've done the entire said who i'm voting for thing before, and i almost ruined a friendship by doing it. I've learned to not. You might say that it's silly, and it was, but i don't like putting things like that up, i'd rather keep it secret, and call it good

Pikamoar

PureNerd

PikamoarAw darn it, I was going to vote for the loser

Don't do that, vote for which ever one you like better, Don't pitty the losing side because the whole point of this poll is to decide which is better

Only reason i would've was because i liked both equally. But I have decided, but i'm going to keep my vote private

If you like them both equally and can't decided don't vote,
and why keep your vote a secret? No ones gonna judge you for it, besides I already know who you voted for so if it's because you think I'll disagree because of why you made the choice, than I assure you, I won't. Your vote is your vote

PureNerd

PikamoarAw darn it, I was going to vote for the loser

Don't do that, vote for which ever one you like better, Don't pitty the losing side because the whole point of this poll is to decide which is better

Only reason i would've was because i liked both equally. But I have decided, but i'm going to keep my vote private

Kefka

Zitzabis

Oops, I guess I wasn't clear enough on what I was meaning. My point was that the idea didn't waver enough from Kefka's past skins. I have no issue with the shading style! In fact...

ZitzabisKefka wins for execution and shading.

I was just expecting a new idea and not sticking with the safe idea.

Oh and Kefka, please don't feel that I'm hating on you. I just feel that people idolize you a bit much sometimes, so a bit of feedback is always a good thing.

yeah, but the whole "same idea" thing doesn't make sense either, UPro has done two other boxer skins before this one. Isn't that the same idea that he has done before too?

Two wrongs don't make a right.

Zitzabis

Oops, I guess I wasn't clear enough on what I was meaning. My point was that the idea didn't waver enough from Kefka's past skins. I have no issue with the shading style! In fact...

ZitzabisKefka wins for execution and shading.

I was just expecting a new idea and not sticking with the safe idea.

Oh and Kefka, please don't feel that I'm hating on you. I just feel that people idolize you a bit much sometimes, so a bit of feedback is always a good thing.

yeah, but the whole "same idea" thing doesn't make sense either, UPro has done two other boxer skins before this one. Isn't that the same idea that he has done before too?

Gotta go with Kefka on this one. The shading looks much cleaner and the use of layers is fantastic.

Kefka FTW

uPro wins my vote, not too sure about the chest shading but the originality and design is superior.

Kefka's skin just looks cleaner and a bit more well executed then uPro's.

I'm sorry, but I'm on Kefka's side.

ZitzabisKefka wins for execution and shading.
But uPro gains the upper-hand with concept. Can't say I like his shading though...

But the main reason why uPro gets my vote is because I've seen Kefka use pretty much that exact same skin style in the past.

vs.

But he did have minor changes, not big one to differentiate each other, but this new one has more details than the old blue one.

Kefka wins for execution and shading.
But uPro gains the upper-hand with concept. Can't say I like his shading though...

But the main reason why uPro gets my vote is because I've seen Kefka use pretty much that exact same skin style in the past.

vs.

Both are very nice, but I feel like Kefka made better use of the palette. It was a hard decision though

Kefka pulling some sick as armour moves. I have yet to see something that impresses me more than that armour.

Kefka - much better shading and use of all layers.

I feel like me voting would be way too biased here :/ so I won't >.< it's so tight!

The score all is all tied up
All though I have to say that I enjoy Kefka's skin more.

Both skins are awesome and the score is a tie.... why?!

Going uPro for the greatness of the skin, it just feels better in my eyes.

They both look and are magnificent, but if I were to choose one to wear, it would be Kefka's because it looks cool (I'm into skins that look like knights and such)

Definitely uPro. Sick shading there, brah.

uPro for originality.

I am voting for Kefka becaus I can see what his skin is used for more than uPro's skin. I have nothing against you, just that I can understand Kefka's skin more.

PikamoarAw darn it, I was going to vote for the loser

Don't do that, vote for which ever one you like better, Don't pitty the losing side because the whole point of this poll is to decide which is better

Aw darn it, I was going to vote for the loser, since i cannot decide. But of course its a tie, so for now, i'm going to abstain

And now i've decided, i'm not going to vote. Gosh darn it seriously guys, making it hard everytime

Both are great skins, shading-wise, and both have great concepts, yet I'm going with uPro's because a boxing Oompa Loompa is much funnier to me and well, that sways me x)

Both are very detailed and magnificent…This is a hard decision..

Hmm..