90
Ticket #54
Status: Closed
Opened by oakley09
- Finished
Type:
Feature Request
Views:
11,562
Access:
Public
Opened:
1/22/16 2:08 pm 1/22/16 2:08 pm
Updated:
3/1/19 1:17 pm 3/1/19 1:17 pm

Profile comments

Just another thing that got to my mind the other day. Wouldn't it be a nice addition?
If anyone wanted to address something to the person behind all the work rather than commenting on one specific submission, profile comments would be the perfect place for that.
I see that there are already options to do so, by either sending a PM, starting a forum post or just writing a comment on one single submission - I don't think that's quite the same though.

03/01/2019 1:17 pm
Level 69 : High Grandmaster Group
Cyprezz
set status to Closed, set resolution to Finished.
Added a "Guest Book" widget!
1
02/20/2019 11:06 pm
Level 46 : Master Professor
Eli the Zeratoed
This is a great idea! It kind of reminds me of the channel comments system from the Old 2005-2011 YouTube, and as someone who loves the nostalgic feeling of that used-to-be-wonderful site, I'm all for this widget! :3
03/23/2017 3:54 pm
Level 72 : Legendary Wizard
oakley09
modified ticket description.
1
03/23/2017 8:47 am
Level 69 : High Grandmaster Group
Cyprezz
I originally thought I'd incorporate this into the wall widget but I think there's a fair number of members that would prefer not to have others posting on their wall. I could have made it an opt-in or opt-out feature on the wall but I think a better solution will be creating a separate guest book widget. What do you think? That way it's up to each member whether or not they want others posting on their profile page and it will keep a nice neat & manageable log for those that do.
1
03/23/2017 3:51 pm
Level 72 : Legendary Wizard
oakley09
That's definitely the right approach. Making it the members' decision whether or not they want public comments on their profiles sounds like a reasonable solution to me, considering that people's opinions on the matter seem to diverge greatly. Thanks for listening to what the community has to say and for being open to new suggestions!
1
01/05/2017 8:27 pm
Level 48 : Master Toast
yeol
souds nice <3
i also want a profile
background image. lol
1
01/05/2017 10:25 am
Level 1 : New Explorer
CSploit
if we could do profile comments it would be great! it should definetly be added

+1 upvote
1
09/24/2016 4:55 pm
Level 28 : Expert Musician
Autumn Fyre
Yes, I agree. If I wanted to simply say "hello," or "thank you for the sub," this wold also be a nice thing.
1
08/23/2016 8:43 pm
Level 1 : New Crafter
OfficialSND
yea this would be awesome
1
06/20/2016 7:27 am
Level 40 : Master Architect
Craft
This would VERU nice.

but also would be nice if there was a diss tasteful comment on the page that's the profile page you could delete it, without waiting on moderators.

^Whether to clean out the comment section to be clean or stop trolls would help so moderators aren't spammed by this.
1
02/12/2016 10:04 pm
Level 27 : Expert Dolphin
asixn
That would be amazing!
1
02/08/2016 5:56 pm
Level 60 : High Grandmaster Bunny
LeafySeaRabbit
Oh hell yeah
1
02/02/2016 1:10 pm
Level 16 : Journeyman Warrior
Shinyn
That would be so cool!
01/26/2016 1:00 pm
Level 69 : High Grandmaster Group
Cyprezz
set status to In Progress.
01/25/2016 2:22 pm
Level 55 : Grandmaster Cyborg
Pepijn
set status to Accepted.
1
01/25/2016 10:30 am
Level 69 : High Grandmaster Group
Cyprezz
This is coming in the member profile update.
1
01/23/2016 6:38 am
Level 55 : Grandmaster Cyborg
Pepijn
I don't see much value gained from this, the only difference with PM's is that these 'comments' would be public and I don't see how that can be of any value.
1
01/22/2016 9:21 pm
Level 45 : Master Architect
Anakiiin
Very nice idea, I think this will be great to have.

Adding on to it, maybe have a little button where you can flag comments that are disrespectful or include profanity, and the PMC staff can handle that.
1
01/22/2016 9:07 pm
Level 12 : Journeyman Network
Ralex
Let me tell you about MCF. We permit comments, but they really provide 0 value to users. They rarely get used from what I seen, or are not really worth having a system to handle. (Case in point: http://www.minecraftforum.net/members/Lord_Ralex/comments). I just see mods having this same problem, and users not getting much benefit.

While it's nice to have, it really to me is not something that is worth having.
01/22/2016 7:12 pm
Level 63 : High Grandmaster Hero
Jackie1st
assigned Developers/Administrators.
1
01/22/2016 5:40 pm
Level 25 : Expert Crafter
idk lol
I do like this idea, as it is like a chatroom on your profile. I for one think this should be implemented, unless there are any problems it could cause to the site.
1
01/22/2016 3:28 pm
Level 38 : Artisan Modder
GiantNuker
*Thumbs Up*!!!
1
01/22/2016 2:12 pm
Level 40 : Master Botanist
candle_
I like that. It could work without giving XP as well, and allow for some public discussions. Given how comments and forums are going to be very similar if not the same in the new system, from what I've heard, it could work pretty well, I think.
Planet Minecraft Logo

Website

© 2010 - 2020
www.planetminecraft.com

Welcome