39
Ticket #18113
Status: Open
Opened by Allergy_Man
Type:
Feature Request
Views:
1,077
Access:
Public
Opened:
8/31/22 12:43 pm 8/31/22 12:43 pm

Updating The HD Skin Preview To 2D

Right now it's difficult to see the quality of an HD skin on the current preview. Everyone I have interacted with has thought a 2D preview that matches the standard preview would be an improvement over the current HD preview. I know the site is currently using the same 3D preview for all the textures, but player skins could benefit the site and artists from having a clearer image.

I know you guys are busy updating the site right now, and this isn’t a priority, but I'm hoping it could possibly be a quicker implementation if you wanted to add it. Maybe even just an edit of the old code since really the only difference from the standard player preview is the scale. Things are never that easy though haha.

Using ThatGuyJake's most recent skin as my example to look at the difference:



vs

Create an account or sign in to comment.

3
09/07/2023 3:51 pm
Level 55 : Grandmaster Batman
JustaFlqmingo
JustaFlqmingo's Avatar
yes yes yes we need this sm
4
09/03/2023 12:43 pm
Level 74 : Legendary Vampire
Drzzter
Drzzter's Avatar
yes yes a thousand times yes
5
09/01/2023 5:20 pm
Level 72 : Legendary Pixel Painter
Nighthearted
Nighthearted's Avatar
The current angle of the HD skins really limits the amount of detail visible since only ~80% of the height is used to show the front plane of the skin. It would be nice if it was tilted just a lil upwards and fully illuminated from the front. Readability is key in thumbnails! I find myself often scrolling past HD skins because my eyes can't make out what's going on in the thumbnail from a quick glance. Really hoping we get this update.
4
09/01/2022 9:49 am
Level 88 : Elite Scapegoat
Paril
Paril's Avatar
Yeah, I wanted to move them all over to that preview but the judges weren't happy with that idea, lol
6
09/01/2022 12:43 pm
Level 58 : Grandmaster Meme
Allergy_Man
Allergy_Man's Avatar
Unless you mean move all player skins to the 3D preview... I would be truly horrified.
4
09/03/2022 5:10 am
Level 88 : Elite Scapegoat
Paril
Paril's Avatar
Yea, all of them. For consistency. But maybe just HD is a good enough compromise.
10
09/22/2022 7:03 pm
Level 53 : Grandmaster Nerd
Noobator
Noobator's Avatar
To further add on to PureNerd's reply, and having thought about this a few times now, I thought I'd bring up a couple of tweaks that I think most skinners would appreciate:
  • No imposed lighting. We spend so much time working with and tweaking colours/contrast, but artificially darkening the model can seriously undermine that intent. I think this significantly improves the overall clarity, also.

  • Ditch the isometric view for a lower y-axis angle. The current one results in the head obscuring far too much of the torso, which is kind of the core part of a design for many skins, much more-so than the top of the head or shoulders in all likelihood.
I've done a mock-up just to quickly demonstrate these tweaks (as well as facing the skin inwards, which is entirely subjective, but I think looks nicer compositionally)



This is very consistent with how many us already make our own 3D previews to share, and I believe it retains the dynamic look of the current 3D approach without diminishing any artistic choices.
In any case, thanks for taking the time to read!
6
09/22/2022 7:26 pm
Level 55 : Grandmaster Goblin
SharkyBoy
SharkyBoy's Avatar
Agreed! This preview does wonders for the skin. It's so much more clear! Not only do I think it works well from the artist's viewpoint, but I think that in general, seeing it this way is much more eye-catching and would result in more people being able to comprehend what the skin is before clicking on it.
7
09/21/2022 3:55 pm
Level 60 : High Grandmaster Batman
PureNerd
PureNerd's Avatar
What about a further compromise where the 3D previewer design is tweaked? Because looking at the skin in a 3D space is a better idea by far, I just think it can be improved upon with tweaks, that would overall make a big difference.
2
09/01/2022 12:41 pm
Level 58 : Grandmaster Meme
Allergy_Man
Allergy_Man's Avatar
based

Is persuasion still possible?...
Planet Minecraft

Website

© 2010 - 2024
www.planetminecraft.com

Welcome